Back to Blog Posts

Why is EVERYONE Getting Priced Out? (WHAT'S REALLY GOING ON?)

Posted by
Share
Share
Share
Share

Did you know that the US is facing a staggering 7-15 million unit housing deficit? What if I told you that the policies meant to prevent another housing bubble actually created this massive shortage? It sounds crazy, but it’s true.

In the video above and the narrative below, we’re diving into the mind-boggling series of events that led to our current housing crisis. From demographic blindspots to climate change impacts, we’re leaving no stone unturned.

Thanks to data from HousingWire and USC researchers, we’re exposing the real causes behind the biggest housing crunch of your life. Ready to have your mind blown? Stick around to discover how this perplexing situation unfolded and what it means for you.

The Hidden Tsunami: A 7-15 Million Unit Housing Deficit

Let’s talk about a major issue affecting homebuyers and sellers – the massive housing shortage we’re facing right now. If you’ve been house hunting and everything seems way out of your budget, you’re not imagining things. There’s a real reason behind it.

Let’s break it down. Experts at USC say we’re short 7 million housing units, while housing analyst Kevin Erdmann puts it at 15 million. That’s not just a small hiccup in the market – we’re talking about a housing deficit that’s bigger than the entire population of some states. It’s like if every single person in Pennsylvania suddenly needed a new home. Can you imagine the chaos?

This shortage isn’t just a figure on a spreadsheet; it’s impacting families across the country, as I showed in a recent article and video. We’re witnessing bidding wars more dramatic than any reality TV show, with prices skyrocketing and pushing many people to abandon their homeownership hopes. It’s a tough reality, especially for those who spent years saving for a down payment.

But here’s the kicker – this problem didn’t just pop up overnight. It’s been brewing for a good 20 years. We’ve got a perfect storm of policy mistakes, demographic shifts, and even climate change making things worse. The average time to find a home has gone up significantly. If you’re out there looking, you might feel like you’re in a never-ending game of musical chairs, and when the music stops, all the chairs are filled.

Now, this isn’t just about housing – it’s about our resilience to other disasters too. Professor Dowell Myers at USC says, “A tightly constrained housing supply reduces resilience to absorb losses from unexpected disasters — fires, earthquakes, hurricanes and more.” When housing is scarce, people might have to choose between an affordable home in a flood-prone area or no home at all.

Take the recent California wildfires, for example. The housing shortage in LA meant many people were living in fire-prone areas with fewer evacuation options. When 90,000 people got evacuation orders, the lack of available housing made it harder to relocate them quickly and safely. It’s a domino effect that we’re only starting to understand.

But it’s not all doom and gloom. Understanding the problem is the first step to solving it. We’ve got smart people working on this, coming up with new ideas and policies to address the shortage. But it’s going to take time, political resolve, and all of us being aware and involved in the process. We can tackle this together, one step at a time.

Get Our Free Market Update

Weekly Special real estate report covers the Tallahassee real estate market

Other buyers, sellers, lenders, and real estate agents have this critical information, and now you can too!

Get immediate access to our most recent newsletter.

Let more than 30 years of experience work for you with charts, graphs, and analysis of the Tallahassee housing market.

Each Monday morning we send out a simple, one-page report that provides a snapshot of the Tallahassee housing market. It only takes 2 minutes to read, but it gives you better market intelligence than most real estate agents possess. Just tell us where to send it below!

The Great Divide: Home Values vs. Income Growth

Let’s talk about something that’s been on everyone’s mind lately – the crazy gap between what we’re earning and what homes cost these days. Remember when your grandparents could buy a house on a single income? Those days are long gone, and I’m about to show you why.

Think of it like this: your paycheck’s grown a bit since 1980, but house prices have shot up like a rocket. It’s like your salary’s a bicycle trying to keep up with a motorcycle. Let me break it down for you.

Since 1980, median home values have jumped by a whopping 68.3% when we adjust for inflation. That means we’re comparing apples to apples, taking into account how the value of money has changed over time. But here’s the kicker – our incomes haven’t kept up at all. Median household income has only inched up by 10.1% in the same period. Talk about a mismatch!

This gap is why so many of us are struggling to buy homes today. It’s not just numbers on a page – it’s real people facing real challenges. Millennials are putting off homeownership, and we’re seeing more folks renting well into their 30s and 40s.

And renting? That’s no walk in the park either. Rents have gone up by 32.7% since 1980, adjusted for inflation. So whether you’re trying to buy or rent, your wallet’s feeling the squeeze.

This matters because homeownership has always been a key way for Americans to build wealth. But with this growing gap, we’re seeing a whole generation struggle to achieve what their parents could.

Let’s look at how this affects different generations. Younger households, especially those under 30, are hit hardest by this affordability crisis. They’re having to stretch their income much more just to get a foot on the property ladder. In fact, these younger folks are three times more sensitive to income changes when it comes to buying a home compared to those over 50.

This gap isn’t the same everywhere. If you’re in a big city, you’re probably feeling the pinch a lot more than someone in a rural area. Urban areas are seeing much bigger challenges when it comes to affordability. It’s gotten so bad that the age of first-time homebuyers keeps going up.

This trend is having some serious long-term impacts on our economy. We’re talking increased financial strain on younger households, reduced wealth accumulation, and potentially even a decline in overall economic mobility. When homeownership becomes less attainable, it doesn’t just affect individual families – it ripples out to the broader economy.

The Pendulum Swing: From Bubble to Bust to… Oops

Remember the 2008 housing crash? Well, buckle up, because we just created an even bigger problem trying to fix it. The pendulum swung too far in the other direction, and now we’re facing a full-blown housing crisis.

After 2008, policymakers tightened mortgage standards to prevent another meltdown. They made it harder to qualify for loans by raising credit score requirements, increasing down payment minimums, and scrutinizing income more closely. On paper, it seemed smart. But here’s the catch: they went overboard.

Let’s look at a typical homebuyer. Before 2008, they could’ve easily qualified for a mortgage with a decent credit score and stable job. Now? They’re struggling to get approved, even with a solid down payment saved up. This is happening all over the country.

The Urban Institute’s data backs this up. As of 2024, mortgage credit availability is way below reasonable lending standards – we’re talking pre-bubble levels from 2001 to 2003. It’s tougher than ever to get a home loan.

But wait, there’s more. While policymakers were making mortgages near-impossible to get, they forgot about demographics. The national birthrate jumped 32% from 1976 to 1990. By 2010, we had a wave of young adults ready to buy homes, but the Great Recession delayed their plans.

So when these folks finally entered the housing market, guess what? Not enough homes. Why? Because policymakers also limited funds for new construction after 2008. Less money for building meant fewer homes right when we needed them most.

The result? A rental shortage that quickly became a homeownership crisis. More people want homes, fewer homes are being built, and it’s harder to get a mortgage. It’s a perfect storm of housing market chaos.

Here’s the kicker: the Urban Institute found that tightening credit and construction funding after 2008 actually dropped homeownership rates 2.3 points lower than they would’ve been under stricter, pre-bubble standards. We tried so hard to prevent another bubble that we made it even harder for people to buy homes than before the crisis!

Can’t we just build more homes now? Not so fast. The Urban Institute says we need to change our whole approach. Instead of reacting to current needs, we need to anticipate demand over the next five years. But the lag time for creating new homes is too long. By the time we realize we need more houses, it’s already too late.

We’re always playing catch-up in this housing game, and that’s a problem we can’t afford to ignore. The unintended consequences of our post-2008 policies have created a housing market that’s more challenging than ever for potential homeowners. I recently posted a solution from the National Housing Crisis Task Force’s policy recommendations to address home affordability and the current housing meltdown.

The Millennial Mirage: Demographic Blindspots

Despite all the doom and gloom you’ve heard, 43% of millennials now own homes. But here’s the kicker – it took them way longer to get there than their parents or grandparents. Let’s dive into the housing crisis that’s affecting not just millennials, but multiple generations.

For years, we heard millennials prefer urban living and aren’t interested in settling down. But that story was way off. When people hit their late 20s, their priorities change. A USC study found that the national birthrate jumped 32% from 1976 to 1990. By 2010, all those babies had grown up and were flooding into cities. Policymakers saw this and thought, “Millennials must love city living!” They missed that it was just a big demographic shift, not a permanent change in what people want.

So what happened? Experts doubled down on their wrong guesses. They figured millennials would be happy renting apartments and having roommates forever. They thought this generation was different, that they didn’t want what their parents wanted. But they were dead wrong.

The truth? Millennials wanted to buy homes just as much as earlier generations. They dreamed of backyards and a place to call their own. The problem? There weren’t enough homes for them to buy. This led to a huge mismatch between supply and demand – millions of potential homebuyers with nowhere to go.

Now, you might be thinking, “Didn’t millennial homeownership drop after the Great Recession?” You’re right, it did. But that wasn’t because millennials suddenly decided they didn’t want homes. The USC study showed this decline was misunderstood as a change in what people wanted. Really, it was tough economic conditions and not enough houses to go around.

Picture this: You’re a millennial who grew up during the Great Recession. You finish college, ready to start your life, but the job market’s a mess. You’ve got student debt, wages aren’t going up, and the few homes available cost way too much. It’s not that you don’t want to buy – you can’t.

This misunderstanding had serious consequences. While experts were busy building more rentals and urban apartments, they ignored what people really needed: affordable starter homes. Now we’ve got millions of millennials in their 30s and 40s, ready to buy homes and start families. But where are they supposed to go? The homes they need just don’t exist in big enough numbers.

This problem affects everyone – millennials, Gen Z coming up behind them, and even older folks looking to downsize but can’t find good options. We’re talking about a housing crisis that spans generations, all because experts got it wrong when it came to what millennials really wanted in a home.

When Nature Strikes: Climate Change and Housing

Let’s talk about something that’s shaking up our housing market in ways we never expected – climate change. We’re not just dealing with a shortage of homes anymore; we’re watching them disappear right before our eyes.

Natural disasters are getting more frequent and intense. Wildfires, hurricanes, floods – you name it, we’re seeing it. And each disaster is like a wrecking ball to our already fragile housing situation. Every home destroyed puts more pressure on an already strained market.

The Urban Institute says our ability to bounce back from these disasters is seriously compromised because we don’t have enough housing to start with. If you lose your home in a disaster, where do you go? Options are shrinking fast, and mortgage credit is tight, making it hard to buy a new place even if you wanted to.

This housing shortage is forcing people to live in risky areas. They might end up in flood-prone zones or regions at high risk for wildfires, simply because that’s where they can afford to live. It’s a vicious cycle – the shortage puts people in harm’s way, and then when disaster strikes, it makes the shortage even worse.

Dowell Myers, a professor at USC, put it bluntly: “A tightly constrained housing supply reduces resilience to absorb losses from unexpected disasters.” Our housing shortage isn’t just making it hard for people to find homes – it’s making our entire society more vulnerable.

So, what’s the solution? We need to change how we think about housing policy. It’s not enough to just react to current needs. We need to start anticipating future demand, thinking five, ten, even twenty years down the line. We need policies that plan for different age groups and life stages while considering climate risks.

We need to build more homes, sure, but also in the right places and ways. We need to make our housing stock more resilient to disasters. And we need to do all of this while addressing the affordability crisis that’s been brewing for decades.

This isn’t just about individual homeowners. It’s about our communities, our cities, our entire country. When we can’t absorb losses from these disasters, it strains everything. Emergency services get overwhelmed, local economies take a hit, and people’s lives get uprooted.

As we work to address our housing crisis, we’ve got to keep climate change front and center. It’s not a separate issue – it’s part and parcel of our housing challenges. If we want to build a resilient housing market for the future, we’ve got to start planning for it now.

The Mismatch Madness: Big Houses, Small Families

You know, we’ve been talking about not having enough homes, but here’s a twist – we might actually have too much house. It’s like we’re building mansions in a world that needs apartments.

Let’s look at the numbers. Back in 1980, only about one in five new homes had four or more bedrooms. Now, in 2022, nearly half of all new homes are supersized. That’s more than double in just over 40 years!

But here’s the kicker – while our houses have been growing, our families have been shrinking. In 1960, the average household had about 3.33 people. Today? It’s down to just 2.55. It’s like setting a table for a banquet when you’re dining alone.

In 2020, more than a quarter of all occupied homes had just one person living in them. And over 60% of homes had only one or two people. That’s a whole lot of empty bedrooms collecting dust.

This mismatch is making our housing crisis worse. We’re using more land, materials, and resources to house fewer people. It’s like trying to solve world hunger by making bigger plates instead of more food.

While we’re building these McMansions, we’re not building enough of the homes people actually need. Those smaller, more affordable starter homes that young families and single folks are desperate for? They’re in short supply.

The smart folks over at USC have been crunching the numbers, and they’ve found that this whole situation is a big mess. We’ve totally dropped the ball when it comes to anticipating what kind of homes people need.

Remember those millennials we talked about earlier? The ones who got hit hard by the Great Recession? Well, turns out we really underestimated how many of them would want to buy homes. After the recession, there was this huge surge in millennial demand for homeownership. But guess what? We didn’t have the right kind of homes ready for them.

So now we’ve got this crazy situation where we’re building too many big homes and not enough small ones. It’s like we’re trying to solve a jigsaw puzzle with all the wrong pieces. And you know what happens when supply doesn’t match demand, right? Yep, prices go up. Way up.

This mismatch isn’t just inefficient – it’s making our housing affordability crisis even worse. We’re wasting resources on houses that are too big, while millions of Americans are struggling to find homes they can actually afford. It’s time we start building smarter, not just bigger.

The Road Ahead: Solutions and Strategies

Alright, buckle up because we’re about to turn this housing crisis on its head. You know that feeling when you finally figure out a tricky puzzle? That’s what we’re aiming for here with housing. We’ve got some game-changing solutions that could revolutionize how we approach this mess.

Let’s talk about predicting future housing needs. The Urban Institute says we need to anticipate housing demand over the next five years. It’s like having a crystal ball for the housing market. If we know what’s coming, we can actually prepare for it. We could avoid the whole “Oops, we didn’t see that coming” situation we’re in now with millennials.

But here’s the kicker – we can’t just look at housing on its own. We need to combine tracking of population growth and housing supply. They’re two sides of the same coin. You can’t understand one without the other. It’s like riding a bike with one pedal. You won’t get far.

Now, here’s where it gets a bit more complicated. We need policymakers to plan for different age groups and their life stages. Not everyone needs the same kind of housing at the same time. Young singles, growing families, empty nesters – they all have different needs. And those needs change over time.

Remember how we talked about natural disasters making this whole situation worse? Well, we need to build more resilient housing that can actually stand up to these disasters. It’s not just about having enough homes, it’s about having homes that last.

And speaking of the right kind of homes, we need to build smaller, more efficient ones for smaller households. Remember those big houses we talked about earlier? Yeah, we need to dial that back a bit. Build smarter, not bigger.

Now, I know what you’re thinking. This all sounds great, but can we actually do it? Well, it’s not going to be easy, that’s for sure. But we’ve got the tools. We’ve got the data. We just need the will to make it happen.

Look, the housing crisis is complex. It’s not something we’re going to solve overnight. But with the right strategies, we can start to turn things around. We can create a housing market that actually works for people, not against them. It’s time to flip how we think about housing policy and make a major shift.

Where We Go From Here

It’s clear this mess didn’t happen overnight. But here’s the thing – understanding how we got here is just the first step. Now it’s time for action. We need policymakers, builders, and even you, the homebuyer, to start thinking differently about housing.

So what can you do? Well, you can start by getting involved in local housing initiatives. Support organizations that focus on affordable housing. And hey, don’t be afraid to speak up and advocate for policies that look ahead. We need to anticipate housing demand and promote sustainable construction practices. It’s not just about today – it’s about building a housing market that works for everyone, now and in the future.

Look, I know this stuff can be heavy. If you want to see how real families are struggling in this market, check out my recent video. Just click that box on the right side of your screen. Trust me, it’ll give you a whole new perspective on what we’re dealing with here.

Related Posts