Search Listings

The Great Real Estate Listing Syndication Hoax

Bravo to Edina Realty in Minnesota, they have put their large foot down and have decided to reign-in the real estate listing syndication systems that are competing for the home buying and home selling consumer.

Yesterday, the Inman News website reported that Edina announced that "its listings will disappear from the last national portal it was providing listings to, Realtor.com, within 10 days."

As one of the largest independent real estate brokerages in the US, an action against the status quo should be worthy of the attention of Realtors around the country. And to anybody who is trying to understand how the internet has impacted the way that to sell a home today.

The Value Of Real Estate Listing Syndication

There is so much more going on with this announcement than Edina or Inman is letting on. This is not really about the accuracy of the information, rather it is about the control of information gathered by the real estate company.

The value of real estate listing syndication systems is debated on a regular basis, but rarely if ever by companies or organizations that actually measure their impact on home sales in any given market.

What most real estate agents fail to grasp about real estate listing syndication can best be explained by the law of diminishing returns. Most agents feel that "more is better," so the more real estate listing syndication sites, the better the exposure of the homes for sale, and the greater likelihood of getting a home sold.

And to an extent, they are right... But not really.

As an extreme example, if I were to but a billboard on top of Mount Everest featuring a home for sale, it would not hurt or diminish my ability to get the home sold. But would it really help?

This is where the law of diminishing returns tells us that "more and more" real estate listing syndication websites do not really provide a benefit to getting a home sold, enough is enough.

The Future Of Real Estate Listing Syndication

So if Edina pulled some of its real estate listing syndication, what was their real motivation?

I think the simple answer is control. Why are we "giving" our hard-earned data to Realtor.com? We know that it won't get homes sold!

Before you start defending the use of large aggregator sites, you have to ask yourself a very important set of questions:

  1. Are all MLS listings getting sent to Realtor.com? (currently, yes for most US housing markets).
  2. What percentage of MLS listings are selling? (currently, less than 50% for most markets).
  3. If more than half the homes that go to Realtor.com are failing to sell, is Realtor.com really the proximate cause for the minority that do sell?

Think about it, real estate listing syndication already reaches over 94% of the market, more sites that feature properties will not enhance your ability to sell a home. The real secret is understanding the difference between "house viewing sites" versus local real estate websites where ready-buyers congregate.

Joining Edina In The Fight Against Real Estate Listing Syndication

Tallahassee MLS Real Estate Listing Syndication Joe Manausa Real Estate 1140 Capital Circle SE #12A Tallahassee, FL 32301 (850) 366-8917 www.manausa.comJust as I have found that more than 70% of the homebuyers in Tallahassee are using one particular property search tool, I suspect that Edina has measured and found that most of the ready buyers in their market are already on their popular regional website.

Thus, any real estate syndication to Realtor.com is going to dilute the market with non-regional players who only plan to add to the cost of buying a home (through fees charged to consumers, Realtors, and lenders for the "traffic" that Realtor.com generates).

And this is not really about Realtor.com, it's about all the no-value-added real estate listing syndication sites that are trying to pull another buck out of the deal when you choose to buy or sell a home. Most consumers start on these sites, but they end up migrating to regional sites (like manausa.com) to find the content and tools that they need to use to make a local real estate transactional decision.

If more large brokers will join Edina and pull away from real estate listing syndication, we will see the preservation of the local real estate expert.

But the contrary is true as well, and if the large real estate listing syndication sites have their way, we will see fewer local real estate experts and the move to Caveat Emptor in the residential real estate industry.


Joe Manausa Real Estate is a brokerage company headquartered in Tallahassee, Florida. Its unique business model provides specialists to both home sellers and home buyers, and the results speak for themselves. JMRE has significantly more 5-star reviews on google than any other local competitor. Joe Manausa Real Estate is a leader in internet marketing and utilizes search engine optimization, email marketing, social media and data analytics to get their clients’ home sold faster and for more money than any other Tallahassee brokerage firm. For more information, visit www.manausa.com or call us at (850) 366-8917.

Discussion

#1 By David at 7/11/2017 3:47 AM

Quit whining about diminishing returns and the technological progress of listing and selling via syndication. Realtors CHARGE WAY TOO MUCH for the little they do anyway. How do I know ? We own 54 single family houses.

#2 By Joe Manausa, MBA at 7/11/2017 3:47 AM

Gee David, I didn't know that I was whining... you seem awfully bitter about what most Realtors charge for the work provided. But the article was about real estate listing syndication and the fact that it misleads (you) consumers into believing it helps get homes sold. Thanks for stopping by.

#3 By Joe Manausa, MBA at 7/11/2017 3:47 AM

Vicki, for the time being, I won't rock the status quo. Too much going on (good thing), but I will monitor and revisit in the future.

#4 By Lena at 7/11/2017 3:47 AM

No offense, but I wouldn't hold Edina up as a run-of-the-mill area. Having relatives who around the twin cities, I can assure you that Edina is a VERY wealthy area. I kind of doubt that clients there are doing Internet searches there the way that less-well off people do, who are looking for a certain price range.

The second thing is that what make you think that Realtor.com doesn't sell homes? We've certainly toured homes for sale on Realtor.com and signed a contract for one we found on that site. We've been able to keep tabs on things on Realtor and followed up with our realtor based on the selection on that site. It would be too difficult to search every realtor's individual site every day.

I'm not quite sure why any realtor wouldn't like the exposure the site gives them.

Post a Comment

Blog Navigation

Posts By Category

All Categories Advice: Real Estate (476) Blogging Real Estate (189) Distressed Property (31) Foreclosures (3) Glossary of Real Estate Terms (31) Government and Real Estate (30) Homes For Sale (105) Housing Market Conditions (1227) Housing Report (54) Lis Pendens (4) Main (1025) Mortgage / Finance (70) New Construction (1) Off Topic (83) Our Listings (3) Our Sales (7) Real Estate Market Snapshot (25) Real Estate Opinion (3) REALTOR News (11) Tallahassee (89) Tallahassee Neighborhoods (397) Uncategorized (50)

Posts By Month

Blog Roll

Homes For Sale In Killearn Lakes Plantation Homes For Sale In Killearn Estates Homes For Sale In Southwood Homes For Sale In Killearn Acres Homes For Sale In Summerbrooke Homes For Sale In Golden Eagle Plantation Homes For Sale In Piney Z Homes For Sale In Bull Run Homes For Sale In Betton Homes For Sale In The Ox Bottom Area

Tag Cloud

Grab Our RSS Feed

Tallahassee Home Searches

Contact Us

Joe Manausa Real Estate
2066 Thomasville Rd
Tallahassee, FL 32308
(850) 366-8917

© Joe Manausa. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy|Terms of Use|DMCA Notice