While newly built homes might be all the rage today, there’s something special about the older homes in Tallahassee that buyers must understand.
First and foremost, buyers should know that there are trends in real estate that are not unlike fashion trends, and this means “what is popular” has a tendency to change right about the time you’ve decided what you want.
But today, we’ll address the one thing that older homes have that will always be in style, and it’s the most important factor in the long-term value of a home. First, let’s look at all the older homes for sale in Tallahassee and see if you can spot the common benefit the majority of these properties possess.
Older Homes For Sale In Tallahassee
The following list of homes for sale includes all listings where the home was built from 1950 or prior.
Older Homes For Sale In Tallahassee
The one thing that nearly all the older homes for sale in Tallahassee share is the fact that they are built in high-demand locations. Think about it.
The people who got here first built their homes in locations that had great access to town. Now that doesn’t mean that our surrounding communities don’t have value, what it says is that the closest locations were taken first.
As somebody who has owned many homes, from brand-new to one nearly 100 years old, I can tell you that I favor newer homes, but I love the older home locations. I recommend all buyers consider if it would be advantageous to live closer to work. How many hours per week would they save from driving to and from the office (unless they work from home now
).
Joe Wrote The Book On How To Sell A Home Today
WARNING: The Internet & digital marketing systems have changed the way sellers need to market a home for sale. It's not about getting a home sold anymore, it's about getting a home sold and netting the most money from the sale.
To do this, a seller needs to hit the digital market hard in a coordinated effort that alerts ready-buyers (all at the same time) to ensure buyers understand they are competing for the right to buy the home.
While it only takes ONE buyer to sell a home, it takes MULTIPLE BUYERS for the seller to bid the property up to its highest value in today's market. You see our full explanation about how to sell a house here, or you can buy the book and really get into the nuts and bolts of selling a home in the digital age.
Get the book that explains it all, in a manner that is understanding to all, even technology neophytes. It's available on Amazon, a trusted source for consumers.
The Average Price Of Older Homes
The average price of the older homes sold in Tallahassee in 2021 has shot up nearly 62% over last year’s average.
The average older home price in Tallahassee is now up to an all-time high of $348K. Owners of older homes need to know that pre-marketed homes are selling very fast and often above the asking prices. Age does not seem to be a factor in 2021.
Currently, there are 52 older homes for sale in Tallahassee and 25 of them (48%) are already under contract with buyers.
Average Older Home Values
The average older home value in Tallahassee has already risen more than 10% over the average value recorded in 2020 (which was 9.3% higher than the full 2019 average). The sale of older homes is exploding right now.
This graph simply measures the price per square foot of all older home sales in the Tallahassee MLS, and the results are incredible. Currently, the average value of homes built from 1950 and earlier is $169 per square foot.
The Average Size Of Older Homes In Tallahassee
The average size of older homes sold in Tallahassee typically falls in a range of 1,400 to 1,650 square feet, but the larger older homes have dominated the sales board in 2021.

The six older homes sold in 2021 were measured at an average size of 2,260 square feet.
Recent Sales Of Older Homes
The following list includes the most recent older home sales in Tallahassee.
Recent Older Home Sales
Top Tips For Home Sellers
How To Sell Your House On Your Own
10 PROVEN Strategies To Increase A Home's Selling Profit
2025s HOTTEST Home Selling Strategies You Need NOW
The 3-DAY Method To Sell Your Home For More (2025)
The Best Time To Lower The Price In A Home Sale
How FOMO Makes Your Home Sale More Profitable
Home Sale Sabotage: Top 10 Mistakes Sellers Make
Thousands of Joe Manausa Team customers have left reviews on Google, Facebook, and Zillow. Read the Tallahassee real estate agent reviews.
Ozzy Gonzalez
Mark Sepulveda
Carson Outler
Al Perruzzi
Quentin D. Wilson
Lexi Harris
Chris Snow
Vanessa Arroyo
Mike McGrotha
Danielle Neilson
Rich Ramos
Whitney Davis
Kim Windham
Jennifer Goldstein Hatfield
Ashley Hamilton
Jenna Harper
Kristy Cooke
Lauren Russell
Tiffany Norris
Kawana Williams
Secily Carter
Janna Peebles
Mark Snyder
Lucila Capdevila
Jocelyn Damelio
Sara Randall-Macdonnell
jason ryan
Ron
Sam Norris
Lindsay Brennan
Mike DalBon
Elizabeth W.
Tori Deas
Cookie
Carolyn Shipley
Ron Barineau
Sally Donnelly
Rob Harris
Kerri Andrade
Michael Henderson
David Jenness
Brittany Holmes
Allison Taylor
Justin Jacks
Tara Carter
Barbara Fink
Devin Baker
Denice Hale
Audrey Campbell
montepfm
Carley Rogers
Kari Follick
Elisabeth Draper
Norene Milligan
P&S - Tallahassee, FL
Ready to talk to a local expert?
Moving to, within, or from Tallahassee, a Joe Manausa Team member gives you the local answers a smooth transaction needs.




