Heartwood Hills Homes for Sale and Market Trends November 2025

Posted by
Share
Share
Share
Share

Heartwood Hills, positioned in northeast Tallahassee, offers spacious residences on generous 1.5- to 4.4-acre home sites.

Set in northeast Tallahassee, Heartwood Hills features spacious homes on generous 1.5 to 4.4 acre home sites.

Buyers value the neighborhood’s diverse architecture, flexible floor plans, and budget-friendly pricing. Most residences span 1,500 to 3,600 square feet and generally sell for under $500,000.

Heartwood Hills Homes For Sale

1 Property
10515 Faye Way
Tallahassee, FL,
Beds5Baths3MLS#395023

Heartwood Hills School Zones

Heartwood Hills is served by the following Leon County public schools:

This report features interactive charts detailing average home prices, values, and sizes, along with a full log of recent sales in Heartwood Hills.

Each visual combines yearly closed transactions (red columns, left axis) with one primary housing indicator (blue line, right axis) for easy comparison across time.

Historic numbers include data through December, while 2025 covers activity through October. Both the charts and the sales table are updated frequently. Bookmark this page to access the most current market insights.

Heartwood Hills Home Prices

Through 2025, four homes have sold for an average of $483K, reflecting nearly a 4 percent increase compared with last year’s single recorded sale.

Average Home Price

Turnover remains limited, consistent with long-term trends. Homeowners tend to stay in place, signaling lasting appeal rather than any softness in demand. Only one property is currently listed, and it is already under contract.

Heartwood Hills Home Values

With few transactions and limited inventory, average values can fluctuate significantly from one sale to the next.

Average Home Value

As of November 3, 2025, sales have averaged $202 per square foot.

Get Our Free Market Update

Weekly Special real estate report covers the Tallahassee real estate market

Other buyers, sellers, lenders, and real estate agents have this critical information, and now you can too!

Get immediate access to our most recent newsletter.

Let more than 30 years of experience work for you with charts, graphs, and analysis of the Tallahassee housing market.

Each Monday morning we send out a simple, one-page report that provides a snapshot of the Tallahassee housing market. It only takes 2 minutes to read, but it gives you better market intelligence than most real estate agents possess. Just tell us where to send it below!

Heartwood Hills Home Size Overview

Most homes in Heartwood Hills span 2,000 to 3,000 square feet, and the 2025 market continues to follow this pattern.

Average Home Size

In 2025, four closed sales averaged 2,411 square feet of heated and cooled living space.

Sales History for Heartwood Hills

Records begin in 2007, and the table below lists every transaction, click any column header to sort the results.

Recent Home Sales In Heartwood Hills

AddressPricePrice / SQFClosing DateYear BuiltSQFSale Type
10571 N Valentine$385,000$2252025-10-3019971,710Resale
10609 N Valentine Road$499,000$1862025-10-2419972,681Resale
10609 Valentine Rd N$499,000$1892025-10-2419972,628Resale
10499 Casanova Drive$540,000$1972025-06-1819952,748Resale
10573 Valentine N Road$506,000$2022025-03-1419972,507Resale
10601 Valentine Road$465,000$1592024-03-1819912,928Resale
10600 Valentine Rd N$368,000$2262023-06-1219941,626Resale
10552 Valentine S Road$413,000$2292023-05-3019931,800Resale
10636 Valentine Road$510,000$1502022-05-2719903,400Resale
10609 Valentine Rd N$375,000$1432022-03-1519972,628Resale
10457 Valentine Road$525,000$1502022-02-1119963,496Resale
10590 Valentine Rd N$467,500$2292021-09-1519912,035Resale
10495 Casanova Drive$484,900$1782021-09-0319962,725Resale
10504 Casanova Drive$416,000$1862021-08-2019932,235Resale
10466 Valentine Road$355,000$1842021-02-1119991,930Resale
10522 Faye Way$499,000$1192020-11-2019994,186Resale
10517 Valentine Road$350,000$1472020-08-1919912,382Resale
1512 Lochinvar Lane$265,000$1522020-07-0219901,744Resale
10465 Valentine Rd S$370,000$1282020-06-0919952,901Resale
10532 Casanova Dr$290,000$1632020-01-0720021,769Resale
10522 Faye Way$253,620$612019-09-3019994,186Resale
10972 Heartwood Hills Boulevard$428,000$1252019-08-2819943,411Resale
1501 Lochinvar Lane$340,000$1362019-08-2619922,500Resale
10522 Faye Way$253,700$602019-07-2319994,186Resale
10625 N Valentine Road$345,000$1572019-04-1719972,193Resale
1602 Shakespeare Drive$305,000$1652018-11-1919981,846Resale
10577 Valentine Road N$357,000$1432018-07-2720022,488Resale
10600 N Valentine Road$255,000$1572018-07-2519941,626Resale
1629 Shakespeare$348,000$1452018-05-3020022,400Resale
10478 Valentine Rd S$284,000$1292017-10-0319982,200Resale
10545 Valentine Rd S$410,000$1232017-09-2520023,346Resale
1513 Lochinvar Ln$261,100$1472017-08-1119961,779Resale
10510 Faye Way$400,000$1332017-06-2620173,004New
10511 Casanova Drive$367,000$1572017-06-0519942,340Resale
10499 Casanova Drive$350,000$1192017-04-2419952,932Resale
10466 Valentine Road$300,000$1552017-03-0319991,930Resale
1513 Lochinvar Ln$78,100$442017-01-1819961,779Resale
10510 Faye Way$122,500$412016-12-3020143,004Resale
10533 Valentine Road$240,000$1402016-12-2919931,720Resale
10505 Valentine Rd S$209,000$872016-10-2819962,392Resale
10520 Casanova Drive$335,000$1462016-10-0719942,288Resale
1622 Shakespeare$367,900$1422016-09-1619952,590Resale
10453 Valentine Rd S$309,000$1332016-06-2920002,322Resale
10503 Casanova Drive$300,000$1582016-06-2419971,895Resale
1610 Baum Rd$195,000$1222016-05-2519951,597Resale
10465 Valentine Rd S$395,000$1322016-05-1819952,998Resale
10980 Heartwood Hills$259,000$1242016-05-1319892,085Resale
1508 Lochinvar Lane$249,900$1362016-05-1119891,841Resale
10610 Valentine Rd N$229,900$1242016-01-2219971,841Resale
10535 Casanova Drive$235,000$1072015-08-3119962,187Resale
10972 Heartwood Hills Boulevard$330,000$972015-06-3019943,411Resale
10610 Valentine Rd N$144,100$782015-06-1619971,841Resale
10972 Heartwood Hills Blvd$196,000$572014-11-2019943,411Resale
10980 Heartwood Hills Blvd$240,000$1152014-08-2919892,085Resale
10504 Casanova Dr$220,000$982014-03-1419932,235Resale
10562 Valentine Rd S$204,000$1132014-02-1819941,802Resale
10525 Valentine Rd S$265,000$1232011-03-1519932,162Resale
10453 Valentine Rd S$287,000$1242010-09-0720002,322Resale
1618 Shakespeare Dr$293,200$1542010-07-0919971,906Resale
10532 Casanova Dr$235,000$1332010-06-1120021,769Resale
1626 Shakespeare Dr$280,000$1232010-05-2719992,271Resale
10646 Valentine Rd N$230,000$1382009-09-0219911,668Resale
10525 Valentine Rd S$253,000$1162009-08-1719932,180Resale
10525 Valentine Rd S$120,000$552009-03-2719932,180Resale
10519 Casanova Dr$259,000$1152008-12-2219962,254Resale
$300,000$1692008-06-2619911,779Resale
$375,000$1532008-05-0119902,446Resale
10478 Valentine Rd S$320,000$1462008-03-1319982,190Resale
10642 Valentine Rd N$345,000$1502007-08-3119992,296Resale
10520 Casanova Dr$345,000$1512007-07-2019942,283Resale
1602 Shakespeare Dr$285,000$1542007-06-1519981,846Resale
1618 Shakespeare Dr$280,000$1472007-03-0219971,906Resale
$263,500$1392007-02-1619891,896Resale
10478 Valentine Rd S$325,000$1482007-01-0419982,190Resale
$300,000$1372006-09-2719892,184Resale
10518 Faye Way$358,000$1292006-08-3119992,766Resale
10473 Valentine Rd S$355,000$1522006-08-0119962,333Resale
1618 Shakespeare Dr$297,500$1562006-07-2719971,906Resale
10509 Valentine Rd S$267,900$1552006-05-0919951,723Resale
10535 Casanova Dr$225,000$1032005-09-1419962,187Resale
10510 Faye Way$215,0002005-06-212005New
10491 Casanova Dr$271,900$1332005-02-2819942,048Resale
10485 Valentine Rd S$249,000$1282005-02-1520001,940Resale
1617 Shakespeare Dr$175,0002004-12-062004New
10466 Valentine Rd S$269,000$1392004-09-2819991,930Resale
10501 Valentine Rd S$258,000$1602004-08-3119981,613Resale
10470 Valentine Rd S$229,500$1272004-08-0119961,803Resale
10481 Valentine Rd S$207,000$962004-06-1519952,156Resale
10515 Faye Way$299,000$1192004-06-0819912,518Resale
10491 Casanova Dr$196,300$962004-02-2719942,048Resale
10593 Valentine Rd N$205,000$992004-02-2519902,074Resale
10474 Valentine Rd S$196,0002004-01-272003New
10600 Valentine Rd N$167,500$1032003-11-2619941,630Resale
10645 Valentine Rd N$185,000$1072003-08-2919931,727Resale
1605 Shakespeare Dr$210,200$1122003-07-2819931,879Resale
10507 Casanova Dr$217,000$972003-07-0919952,248Resale
10499 Casanova Dr$219,000$802003-07-0219952,732Resale
10457 Valentine Rd S$249,900$1092003-04-1019962,287Resale
$177,9002002-12-132002New
$203,0002002-11-062002New
1604 Baum Rd$230,000$892002-10-1419922,578Resale
10473 Valentine Rd S$224,900$962002-09-1419962,333Resale
10551 Casanova Dr$138,500$752002-07-2419971,857Resale
10585 Valentine Rd N$176,700$872002-07-1119902,042Resale
1621 Shakespeare Dr$210,000$852002-07-1119962,458Resale
10524 Valentine Rd S$153,000$962002-07-0819941,587Resale
10645 Valentine Rd N$168,900$982002-05-3019931,727Resale
1605 Shakespeare Dr$190,000$1012002-04-3019931,879Resale
1516 Lochinvar Ln$129,000$972002-03-2219891,330Resale
1618 Shakespeare Dr$177,400$932002-02-2819971,906Resale
10629 Valentine Rd$146,000$862001-12-2719941,692Resale
10593 Valentine Rd N$178,000$862001-12-1719902,074Resale
10457 Valentine Rd S$200,000$872001-08-0219962,287Resale
10545 Valentine Rd S$252,000$712001-08-0220013,525New
$185,000$842001-06-1519972,193Resale
10513 Valentine Rd S$147,900$972001-05-3019991,523Resale
10567 Valentine Rd N$159,000$862001-05-2419891,848Resale
10566 Valentine Rd N$182,500$852001-05-1419902,154Resale
10473 Valentine Rd S$199,000$852001-03-3019962,333Resale
10535 Casanova Dr$180,000$822001-02-2119962,187Resale
1614 Shakespear Dr$140,000$452001-01-3020003,100New
10972 Heartwood Hills Blvd$259,900$762001-01-1119943,415Resale
10980 Heartwood Hills Blvd$172,300$832001-01-0519892,085Resale
10520 Casanova Dr$175,000$772000-11-1319942,283Resale
10552 Valentine Rd S$143,500$802000-10-3019931,800Resale
10470 Valentine Rd S$164,500$912000-10-0219961,803Resale
10543 Casanova Dr$135,000$362000-06-3020003,739New
10485 Valentine Rd S$120,000$502000-06-2320002,386New
10520 Casanova Dr$173,500$762000-04-2819942,283Resale
10453 Valentine Rd$150,600$462000-04-2420003,256New
10537 Valentine Rd S$148,000$512000-04-2420002,905New
1621 Shakespeare Dr$185,000$752000-04-0719962,458Resale
1613 Shakespeare Dr$210,000$712000-03-2320002,968New
1610 Shakespear Dr$172,750$561999-12-1019993,082New
10500 Faye Way$147,000$851999-09-3019961,721Resale
$145,000$861999-08-1219941,692Resale
10477 Valentine Rd S$132,000$731999-07-2019941,806Resale
1625 Shakespeare Dr$157,000$701999-07-1619962,248Resale
1626 Shakespeare Dr$100,000$331999-07-0719993,022New
10617 Valentine Rd N$130,000$831999-06-2419961,566Resale
10513 Valentine Rd S$107,000$441999-05-2719992,431New
10517 Valentine Rd S$178,000$751999-05-2119912,368Resale
10509 Valentine Rd S$140,700$821999-04-3019951,723Resale
10980 Heartwood Hills Blvd$157,500$761999-04-2819892,085Resale
10573 Valentine Rd N$146,000$741999-04-1419971,977New
10499 Casanova Dr$180,500$661999-02-2619952,732Resale
10600 Valentine Rd N$135,000$831998-12-1819941,630Resale
10533 Valentine Rd S$128,500$811998-07-1419931,580Resale
10478 Valentine Rd S$150,000$501998-06-0319982,993New
10457 Valentine Rd S$178,000$781998-03-1019962,287Resale
1605 Shakespeare Dr$136,000$721998-01-3019931,879Resale
10457 Valentine Rd S$159,200$701997-12-3119962,287New
1600 Shakespeare Dr$117,670$411997-12-1019972,852New
10613 Valentine Rd N$81,000$531997-11-261,534Resale
10497 Valentine Rd$150,000$501997-11-0619973,000New
10601 Valentine Rd N$193,000$661997-09-252,916Resale
10506 Faye Way$135,000$601997-06-162,261Resale
10503 Casanova Dr$95,000$381997-04-2419972,482New
1618 Shakespeare Dr$135,200$711997-02-2819971,906New
10610 Valentine Rd N$125,000$481997-02-0619972,608New
10562 Valentine Rd S$129,000$721997-01-2919941,802Resale
1625 Shakespeare Dr$168,000$751996-12-1219962,248New
10511 Casanova Dr$164,000$771996-10-302,140Resale
10470 Valentine Rd S$157,500$871996-10-2919961,803New
10531 Casanova Dr$118,000$321996-10-1719963,633New
10569 Valentine Road North$95,000$461996-10-1419962,080New
1513 Lochinvar Ln$128,900$721996-10-1419961,779New
1517 Lochinvar Ln$138,000$461996-10-0919963,020New
10515 Faye Way$192,300$761996-09-2519912,518Resale
10571 Valentine Rd N$85,000$341996-08-1919962,504New
1609 Shakespeare Dr$127,900$501996-06-142,574Resale
10493 Valentine Rd S$120,000$331996-06-1019963,624New
10505 Valentine Rd S$121,000$511996-02-2219962,384New
10613 Valentine Rd N$117,000$761995-12-1519951,534New
10552 Valentine Rd S$119,900$671995-10-2719931,800Resale
1504 Lochinvar Ln$128,000$641995-08-301,993Resale
10515 Casanova Dr$147,000$401995-02-2719943,660New
10508 Casanova Dr$100,000$381994-12-1319942,620New
10465 Valentine Rd S$152,750$431994-11-2919943,528New
1516 Lochinvar Ln$96,000$721994-11-0819891,330Resale
10481 Valentine Rd S$90,000$321994-10-1119952,796New
1630 Shakespear Dr$175,000$501994-10-1119943,483New
1612 Baum Road$73,000$341994-08-2319942,163New
10601 Valentine Rd N$155,000$531994-06-282,916Resale
10562 Valentine Road South$70,000$321994-05-3119942,175New
10980 Heartwood Hills Blvd$136,000$651994-05-3119892,085Resale
10461 Valentine Road$86,700$351994-05-0319942,499New
10529 Valentine Rd S$135,000$721994-02-211,884Resale
10477 Valentine Rd$100,000$401993-10-0419932,480New
10552 Valentine Rd$116,000$381993-08-3019933,091New
10633 Valentine Rd N$142,500$781993-08-111,838Resale
10509 Faye Way$135,500$391993-07-2019933,440New
1605 Shakespear Dr$69,500$281993-06-2119932,454New
10525 Valentine Road$106,000$371992-12-0219922,851New
10533 Valentine Rd S$75,000$421992-11-0919931,770New
1504 Lochinvar Ln$70,200$351992-07-2119921,993New
1525 Lochinvar Ln$90,000$421992-03-2619922,123New

There are a lot of people who endorse Joe for the job of selling your home, including Preston Scott (host of Tallahassee's top daily "Audio Magazine," as well as the thousands of happy customers Joe has helped in the past. Listen why!

Related Posts

Leon County housing market by quadrant showing supply and demand trends for Northeast, Northwest, Southeast, and Southwest Leon County homes
Housing Market Conditions
Joe Manausa

Leon County Housing Market by Quadrant

Understanding the Leon County housing market requires more than simply looking at price trends. Supply, demand, and transaction activity often vary significantly across different areas

Read More »