The Fallacy Of Affordable Housing: Why The Focus Should Be On Building More Homes

The idea of affordable housing is a noble one, but the reality is that building new low-end homes is not the solution to the housing crisis we're facing

The idea of affordable housing is noble, but the reality is that building new low-end homes is not the solution to the housing crisis we're facing.

In fact, the emphasis on affordable housing may actually be hindering progress toward a more accessible housing market for all.

In today's blog post, we'll explore why the key to solving the housing crisis isn't just about making housing affordable, but rather, it's about building more homes.

Affordable Housing Defined

Here is how FLHousing.org defines affordable housing:

"Affordable housing is defined in terms of the income of the people living in the home. The family must be income eligible. Income eligibility is defined in terms of area median income, adjusted for family size.

  • Low income describes a family at or below 80% of area median income.

The median income is determined by the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) by county or Metropolitan Statistical Areas (MSAs). Median incomes are updated annually by HUD."

To put this into perspective in Tallahassee, our median family income of roughly $81,400 makes our low-income families those that earn less than $65,120. Assuming they have strong credit and little debt, they can typically buy up to about $290K. In Tallahassee, our median home price is around $256K, so in theory, all is good, right?

As we'll see with the first graph in our report, all is not good!

The Supply Of Homes Remains Near An All-Time Low

This graph plots the real supply of existing homes for sale in the US in blue, calculates the months' supply of homes for sale in red (also known as the relative supply of homes), and then records the one-year average of the relative supply of homes for sale. Historically, market equilibrium (balanced market) is achieved when six months supply of homes exists.

Number of homes for sale remains near all-time low

The first thing that jumps out of this graph is that only 980K existing homes are for sale in the US. That is 76% fewer homes than were available in 2006 when the housing market collapsed.

When mortgage interest rates soared after the first quarter last year, many self-appointed real estate experts claimed that inventories of unsold homes would pile up and home prices would plummet. Instead, we see supply falling (nearly) in line with demand. This means the relative supply of homes has not exploded above 6.0 months of supply. Instead, it has ticked up to its current "just off the bottom" level of 2.8 months of supply.

Home sales could very well heat back up as mortgage interest rates have stabilized, and that will only put more heat on the lack of supply of homes for sale in our local housing markets. We need to build more homes.

Get Our Free Market Update

Weekly Special real estate report covers the Tallahassee real estate market

Other buyers, sellers, lenders, and real estate agents have this critical information, and now you can too!

Get immediate access to our most recent newsletter.

Let more than 30 years of experience work for you with charts, graphs, and analysis of the Tallahassee housing market.

Each Monday morning we send out a simple, one-page report that provides a snapshot of the Tallahassee housing market. It only takes 2 minutes to read, but it gives you better market intelligence than most real estate agents possess. Just tell us where to send it below!

Why The US Is Not Building Homes

This graph explains why home construction is not happening in America. Although the data is from the Tallahassee real estate market, it reflects trends in most other US housing markets when focused on the relationship between new and resale price ratios. Tallahassee's absolute values are similar to the national average.

The additional cost of buying a new one versus a used one

This graph was designed to display the long-term cost trends for US housing to understand the additional cost a new home buyer pays when compared to an existing homebuyer.

The red line plots the five-year average of the median price per square foot of new homes, while the blue line plots the five-year average of the median price per square foot of existing homes. The gray line measures the "premium" that new home buyers pay to be the first to own a home. This gray line explains why home construction is not happening in America.

For the twenty-two (22) years ending in 2012, the difference between the cost of new and existing homes was typically just under 10%. This means that a new home that was valued at $100 per square foot in 1995 would be the same size as an existing home valued at $90 per foot. Generally speaking, speculative builders had little risk if they were building quality homes, as "brand new" was only 10% more expensive than "used."

With a relative abundance of shelter in America, the spread between new and used was pretty tight. But then the federal government got involved as it felt the need to crash the housing market. When the housing market was screaming along at warp speed in 2007, the federal government stepped in and eliminated loan opportunities for home buyers with lower credit scores. 

With a mass of buyers removed from the market, builder inventory stacked up, and builders were crushed. Builders with inventory lost everything, while builders without inventory had no buyers to sell to. So they stopped building homes. The cessation of homebuilding has created a void in the US housing inventory of anywhere from 5 million to 10 million homes.

So why doesn't somebody fill the void with new homes?

Just look at the graph. The cost to build new homes soared while the value of existing homes was still reeling from the Federal Government's intervention in 2007. The ten percent differential between new and used homes reached as high as 81% in 2015, while for five years, the difference averaged over fifty percent. In other words, builders could not compete with the cheaper existing homes market, so they were cautious and did not build at historically normal rates.

The yellow arrow highlights the fact that both new and existing home values are higher today than their trajectory would have been forecast in 2005. The cost of new construction materials, buildable land, and wages have taken new construction prices through the roof. The resulting effect is that new home values are pulling up existing home values, and we'll soon be to a point where most families will no longer be able to afford a home.

As I see it, there are only a few ways to fix the housing problem in the US. We either need more shelter, we need to put more people per unit, or we need fewer people.

Are you a NIMBY or a YIMBY?
Two terms have gained prominence over the past few years. NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard) and YIMBY (Yes, In My Back Yard) are labels that classify housing market activists into one of two camps
Home Affordability Falls To 40-Year Low!
It's been over forty years since homes were more expensive than today when you factor in inflation, home prices, and mortgage interest rates.
The Surprising Way Interest Rates Move The Market
When mortgage interest rates change, housing market experts surface and make bold claims on how the market will unfold. They are usually wrong!
Real Story Behind Home Prices: Fact Versus Fiction
When it comes to buying a home, many misconceptions about the housing market can cause confusion and uncertainty for potential homebuyers. One of the most persistent myths is that home prices fall frequently, but is this true?
Biden Rent Control Plan
The White House announced an executive action that Biden says is designed to "protect renters and promote rental affordability," but I cannot imagine a worse response from our Commander In Chief to confront the nation's housing and rental affordability crisis
Will Assumable Mortgages Save Housing?
Will assumable mortgages save housing? Home affordability is becoming one of the hottest topics in the economy, but I was recently asked if assumable mortgages might bring some relief to homebuyers. This video shares what I think about how mortgage assumption will impact housing.
Renter Nation Says Goodbye To The American Dream!
It's the beginning of a generational shift in the housing market that will greatly reduce homeownership and push the US towards becoming a renter nation, one in which Wall Street is in control of both home prices and rents
The Truth About Foreclosures - Mortgage Pipeline Update
The best way to start to analyze the potential for mass foreclosures is to break down the current mortgage pipeline to observe forming trends.
Home Prices Are Doing What?
The hype-headlines are scary, exclaiming falling home prices and the coming housing market crash. Here's what the housing market facts reveal:
Will NINJA Loans Bring Down The Housing Market?
Housing Crash Coming? If you remember back to the housing bubble, we saw the growth of "NINJA" loans, as they were a segment of the home sales explosion.
Google Knows. The Surprising Real Estate Market Forecast You Won't Believe!
Is it possible to forecast home sales in the US housing market with a search on Google? I had this thought about Google and a google housing market forecast as I was reexamining our search engine optimization efforts.
Economic Outlook For The Housing Market
Joe Manausa gives an update on the economic outlook for Tallahassee and the US housing market. Includes housing market forecast, housing market activity, and new construction analysis, and reveals how Tallahassee compares with the overall US housing market.
Will New Construction Bottleneck Cause A New Housing Bubble?
Are you concerned that the bottleneck of builder homes under construction will cause a new housing bubble as they are finally completed?
6 Housing Market Rumors Debunked (1 Confirmed)
7 different housing market rumors are perpetuated as “FACT” in various forms of "hype." Discussion of this "housing market news" has been ongoing for years, so today, I want to put them all to rest.
Who To Blame For Soaring Home Prices
There is a huge shortage of homes in the US, and there is only one culprit to blame, and I’m going to tell you who it is!
What You Don't Know About Home Prices!
Home prices are gaining traction as topics in both the mainstream media and social media, but there are three common misconceptions about the change in house prices that are unanimously reported as unquestionably true.
Is The Supply Of Homes For Sale Finally Rising?
Is The Supply Of Homes For Sale Finally Rising? Is the US housing market heading for a crash? Will home prices fall? Follow the metrics that clearly show what to expect from home prices and the supply of homes for sale in 2022 and beyond.
Zillow Exposes Mainstream Media On Home Prices
Zillow serves up the data that exposes the poor reporting of the mainstream media on Zillow home prices and that conditions are not what they seem.
House Prices - Inflation Adjusted Home Prices
Just How High Are Today's House Prices? The price of houses in the US has risen to a toxic level, and many are wondering how they will be able to afford to live in their local communities
Podcast: Housing Myths Dispelled
Home Building Hero David Belman and Joe Manausa discuss many of the "myths" that have been published in the media about the housing market.
USA Today Misleads Readers About Home Prices
USA Today Misleads Readers About Home Prices - Median Home Price: The USA Today Network has been misleading readers, using the median home price change suggesting that houses are getting cheaper and a real estate crash is upon us. Is this poor journalism or is there something more to it?
Home Affordability Crisis - Major Housing Market Shift
Home affordability is plummeting, and this home affordability forecast explains why real estate prices are becoming less affordable with each passing month.
Are We Overbuilding Again?
I've been asked recently for my opinion on the number of homes being built in the US. Specifically, people are wondering if the ghost of 2006 has come back to bring more homes to the market than what can be consumed?
Housing - Do You Follow Your Gut (Or Analytics) In Housing?
I think the signs in the housing market are loud and clear, yet most real estate reports I read or view are missing the most critical factor in housing today.
Home Ownership Is Radically Different For Millennials
This is a simple millennial housing case study that will clearly show that the millennials will face a housing market like no other generation going back to post-World War II.
When Will Home Prices Fall?
Are Home Values About To Crash AGAIN? Now that we've seen about three years' worth of skyrocketing home prices, prudent buyers with memories are asking when home prices are going to start falling again.
How Often Do Home Prices Fall?
Are home prices falling? Will house prices fall soon? Home prices are soaring, buyers are having to pay above most sellers' asking prices, and the housing market feels just like a feeding frenzy during Shark Week on the Discovery Channel.
What Do Low Mortgage Interest Rates Really Mean?
Every article or video about mortgage interest rates conveys that rates are low, but do you really know what it means?

Tricke Up Or Trickle Down For Housing?

Trickle-up and trickle-down economics are two different approaches to housing policy that focus on different parts of the housing market.

Trickle-down economics is based on the idea that by building more high-end homes, the increased supply will eventually decrease prices as people move into these homes and free up existing homes for lower-income buyers. Proponents of trickle-down economics believe that by increasing the supply of high-end homes, the market will eventually filter down to more affordable homes, making them more accessible to lower-income buyers.

On the other hand, trickle-up economics focuses on building more affordable housing units. Proponents of trickle-up economics believe that by increasing the supply of affordable housing units, it will help increase demand for higher-end homes as people move up the housing ladder.

So which is the likelier method of producing enough affordable homes?

It has to be trickle-down.

The cost of land, sticks, bricks, and labor have risen to where we can no longer profitably produce affordable homes. I can only imagine producing them today through government subsidies (and how could that possibly go wrong?).

We need to embrace the trickle-down solution. Every local housing market must solve this on its own (as poor local governance created the housing problem). They need to figure out the lowest price they can produce homes and then work to help developers and builders flood the market with homes at these prices and higher until the shortage of homes is solved in their market areas. This means incentivizing all forms of housing production, as the supply of housing has been ignored and caused home prices and rents to soar.

I can hear the detractors now. They will say, "Sure, build more McMansions; that won't help the homeless. All you are doing is helping the rich!"

But they are wrong. Very wrong.

Here's a simplified explanation of the trickle-down housing solution. Building more million-dollar homes than are needed will add to the supply of homes that are not needed, so million-dollar home values will begin to fall. These fallen homes will increase the supply of $900K homes, so they will fall in value and become $800K homes. 800 will become 700, and so on. The market forces of supply and demand do work when we allow them.

Ideally, homes that can be produced profitably will be the starting point, and flooding the market with those homes will create a compression zone where home appreciation stagnates and then falls. With the right amount of production, coupled with the wage inflation already in progress, we'll again see the homes we once considered affordable become so again.

The housing problem will not just go away on its own, and the supply shortage will continue to increase the imbalance between the "haves" and "have-nots." We need to work aggressively to solve this national problem, but the work will be required at the local level. Keep this in mind when elections roll around, and you are wondering which candidate deserves your vote. The one that campaigns to fix housing will certainly gain my attention.

Zillow Drops Bombshell Real Estate Update
You won't want to miss the latest data release from Zillow. They've just dropped a bombshell of a report that will significantly impact the housing market.
How Bad Is It? SHOCKING Building Permits Report!
The lack of home affordability has become a widely discussed issue in the media - the shortfall in new single-family home permits and multi-family property permits and construction exacerbates the current housing crisis.
Will New Construction Bottleneck Cause A New Housing Bubble?
Are you concerned that the bottleneck of builder homes under construction will cause a new housing bubble as they are finally completed?
Google Knows. The Surprising Real Estate Market Forecast You Won't Believe!
Is it possible to forecast home sales in the US housing market with a search on Google? I had this thought about Google and a google housing market forecast as I was reexamining our search engine optimization efforts.
The Truth About Foreclosures - Mortgage Pipeline Update
The best way to start to analyze the potential for mass foreclosures is to break down the current mortgage pipeline to observe forming trends.
Renter Nation Says Goodbye To The American Dream!
It's the beginning of a generational shift in the housing market that will greatly reduce homeownership and push the US towards becoming a renter nation, one in which Wall Street is in control of both home prices and rents
The Surprising Way Interest Rates Move The Market
When mortgage interest rates change, housing market experts surface and make bold claims on how the market will unfold. They are usually wrong!
Home Affordability Falls To 40-Year Low!
It's been over forty years since homes were more expensive than today when you factor in inflation, home prices, and mortgage interest rates.
Biden Rent Control Plan
The White House announced an executive action that Biden says is designed to "protect renters and promote rental affordability," but I cannot imagine a worse response from our Commander In Chief to confront the nation's housing and rental affordability crisis
Market Equilibrium, How The Balance Has Changed In Real Estate
The way we estimate housing market equilibrium has changed, and with it, the way the market is evaluated must change.
What You Don't Know About Home Prices!
Home prices are gaining traction as topics in both the mainstream media and social media, but there are three common misconceptions about the change in house prices that are unanimously reported as unquestionably true.
New Home Construction Report
Kevin Erdmann Housing Update September 2022 - Explains the new home construction pipeline and what to know about the number of homes being built in the US.
Home Prices Are Doing What?
The hype-headlines are scary, exclaiming falling home prices and the coming housing market crash. Here's what the housing market facts reveal:
REDFIN Reports Falling Home Prices?
Does the latest Redfin real estate report show home prices falling? I reviewed the Redfin real estate data, but did I find home prices dropping?
Unlocking Zillow's Latest Housing Trends And Forecasts
Zillow has shared its extensive data that we have used to generate our monthly housing market update. Zillow reports this right now:
House Prices - Inflation Adjusted Home Prices
Just How High Are Today's House Prices? The price of houses in the US has risen to a toxic level, and many are wondering how they will be able to afford to live in their local communities
USA Today Misleads Readers About Home Prices
USA Today Misleads Readers About Home Prices - Median Home Price: The USA Today Network has been misleading readers, using the median home price change suggesting that houses are getting cheaper and a real estate crash is upon us. Is this poor journalism or is there something more to it?
Economic Outlook For The Housing Market
Joe Manausa gives an update on the economic outlook for Tallahassee and the US housing market. Includes housing market forecast, housing market activity, and new construction analysis, and reveals how Tallahassee compares with the overall US housing market.
Podcast: Housing Myths Dispelled
Home Building Hero David Belman and Joe Manausa discuss many of the "myths" that have been published in the media about the housing market.
Are Wages Keeping Up With Rising Home Prices
Home prices are rising. Mortgage interest rates are rising. Are people earning enough money to buy homes today, or is the home affordability crisis getting worse?
Zillow - Surprising Home Sales Report
Zillow has something to say about the housing market. Zillow's data suggests something else is happening. And it’s not just Zillow.
Zillow Exposes Mainstream Media On Home Prices
Zillow serves up the data that exposes the poor reporting of the mainstream media on Zillow home prices and that conditions are not what they seem.
Housing - Do You Follow Your Gut (Or Analytics) In Housing?
I think the signs in the housing market are loud and clear, yet most real estate reports I read or view are missing the most critical factor in housing today.
6 Housing Market Rumors Debunked (1 Confirmed)
7 different housing market rumors are perpetuated as “FACT” in various forms of "hype." Discussion of this "housing market news" has been ongoing for years, so today, I want to put them all to rest.
Is The Supply Of Homes For Sale Finally Rising?
Is The Supply Of Homes For Sale Finally Rising? Is the US housing market heading for a crash? Will home prices fall? Follow the metrics that clearly show what to expect from home prices and the supply of homes for sale in 2022 and beyond.
Who To Blame For Soaring Home Prices
There is a huge shortage of homes in the US, and there is only one culprit to blame, and I’m going to tell you who it is!
When Will Home Prices Fall?
Are Home Values About To Crash AGAIN? Now that we've seen about three years' worth of skyrocketing home prices, prudent buyers with memories are asking when home prices are going to start falling again.
Home Ownership Is Radically Different For Millennials
This is a simple millennial housing case study that will clearly show that the millennials will face a housing market like no other generation going back to post-World War II.
Are We Overbuilding Again?
I've been asked recently for my opinion on the number of homes being built in the US. Specifically, people are wondering if the ghost of 2006 has come back to bring more homes to the market than what can be consumed?
Home Affordability Crisis - Major Housing Market Shift
Home affordability is plummeting, and this home affordability forecast explains why real estate prices are becoming less affordable with each passing month.
Why It's Alway About Supply And Demand In Real Estate
It's all about supply and demand. The real estate supply and demand dynamic tells us everything we need to know to forecast home sales in any given area.
Building Permits Reveal Major Housing Crisis
How do we know there is a major housing crisis brewing? Look no further than building permits! This video examines building permits in detail, as the issue of home affordability is going to become one of the most prominent topics for many years in the national media.
Interesting Employment Dynamic Impacts Home Sales
Home sales in the United States are vibrant, and we can look to the economy as a big reason homes are selling. I have found a pocket of data on the Federal Reserve Economic Data website that explains the vitality of the US housing market.
How Often Do Home Prices Fall?
Are home prices falling? Will house prices fall soon? Home prices are soaring, buyers are having to pay above most sellers' asking prices, and the housing market feels just like a feeding frenzy during Shark Week on the Discovery Channel.
What Do Low Mortgage Interest Rates Really Mean?
Every article or video about mortgage interest rates conveys that rates are low, but do you really know what it means?
Homeownership Rate Crash #shorts
60 Second Video: Homeownership is going to decline over the next 30 years, as home affordability hits the worst levels seen since the end of World War II. This is a generational shift in the housing market

Your Local Expert In Tallahassee

When moving to, in, or from Tallahassee, you will fare better if you work with a local expert. We are here to help. If you have further questions on the Tallahassee real estate market, you can leave a comment below, give us a call at (850) 366-8917, or drop us a note and we'll give you the local information needed to ensure a successful, smooth transaction.

As a local born and raised in Tallahassee with a focus on customer service, I promise you'll find great success when working with Joe Manausa Real Estate, just as have our past customers. You can read thousands of their reviews reported on Google, Facebook and Zillow right here: Real Estate Agent Reviews Tallahassee.

The digital marketing guide for small businessesHave you heard about my new book "The Business of Getting Business?" It's a comprehensive guide for small businesses to help them make the move to digital. For those of us who want to survive and thrive in a world where large corporations are taking over, it is a must-read. It's also the perfect guide for how to sell a home in the digital age. You can find The Business Of Getting Business by clicking on any of the trusted retailers below.

Real Estate Agent reveals in Tallahassee, Florida

Think all REALTORS are alike?

Read what people are saying about working with Joe Manausa Real Estate! You can see thousands of real customer reviews reported on Google, Facebook and Zillow at this link: CLICK HERE FOR REAL ESTATE AGENT REVIEWS.

Post a Comment

(850) 378-5727