Timber Lake, nestled in Southeast Tallahassee, is a sought-after residential area featuring single-family homes mainly from the 1980s and 1990s, with some newer builds.
These homes are spacious and well-kept, many boasting expansive backyards and mature greenery. Despite their generous sizes, most homes sit on lots ranging from a tenth to a fifth of an acre, catering to both the younger generation and retirees.
A stone’s throw from downtown Tallahassee, Timber Lake residents have quick access to shopping, dining, and entertainment. Highlights nearby include Tom Brown Park, the Tallahassee Museum, and Governors Square Mall. Plus, with connections to major roads like Capital Circle, Highway 27, and I-10, getting around the city or heading out of town is a breeze.
In sum, Timber Lake offers a blend of convenience, comfort, and nature, making it a top choice for homebuyers in Tallahassee.
Homes For Sale In Timber Lake
Timber Lake Homes for Sale
Timber Lake Schools
Timber Lake is zoned for these Leon County public schools:
This report provides an in-depth look at Timber Lake’s housing trends, featuring charts and graphs on average home prices, values, sizes, and recent sales.
The three real estate graphs in this Tallahassee report present:
- The yearly number of closed home sales (red columns on the left axis).
- A key real estate statistic (in blue on the right axis).
For the latest updates on Timber Lake homes, keep this page bookmarked. Note that the commentary below captures sales up to the fourth week of October in 2023, whereas previous years are documented through December.
Timber Lake Home Prices
In 2023, Timber Lake’s average home price has risen by a little more than 1%, reaching $214K.
Average Home Price
Timber Lake’s housing market is thriving. Homes that are aggressively pre-marketed sell instantly at premium prices.
Currently, two homes are for sale in Timber Lake, with one already secured by a buyer.
Home Values In Timber Lake
At the beginning of the year, Timber Lake’s average home value skyrocketed. However, a recent sale of a distressed home needing major repairs has lowered the average, placing it slightly above last year’s. As more homes close, we anticipate a value explosion.
Average Home Value
Currently, Timber Lake’s average home value stands at $172 per square foot.
Have You Heard About Our Long-Term Shop & Lock Mortgage Program?
In this crazy seller's market, it can be tough to get a home under contract when so many other buyers are bidding on the same home as you. In fact, there are many buyers who have tried and failed multiple times to get homes under contract, and they are facing a problem we have not seen in the past.
Mortgage interest rates are moving higher, and many buyers have found that the rate has grown so much since they first began their home search that they no longer can afford to buy at the price they have been shopping. This is why for many buyers we recommend they evaluate a long-term rate lock that will allow them to shop for up to NINE (9) months without losing their loan commitment.
Simply provide your contact information below and we will help you evaluate the best time and way to utilize a mortgage interest rate lock.
Timber Lake Home Sizes
Homes in Timber Lake usually range from 1,150 to 1,250 square feet, and 2023 is consistent with this trend.
Average Home Size
The six homes sold in 2023 averaged 1,237 square feet each.
Recent Home Sales In Timber Lake
This list showcases Timber Lake’s home sales since 1991. Easily reorganize it by clicking on the column heading of the data you want to sort.
Home Sales in Timber LakeAddress Price Price / SQF Closing Date Year Built SQF Sale Type 4109 Red Cedar Ct $220,000 $218 2026-07-28 1989 1,007 Resale 4102 Cottage Wood Trl $220,000 $179 2026-07-02 1988 1,228 Resale 1562 Sprucewood Trl $215,000 $214 2026-06-12 1988 1,007 Resale 1451 Grey Fox Run $265,000 $212 2026-05-13 1987 1,248 Resale 1551 Sprucewood Trl $251,000 $204 2026-02-12 1988 1,228 Resale 4133 Red Cedar Ct $195,000 $194 2026-02-11 1989 1,007 Resale 4118 Stag Run Ct $275,000 $203 2026-01-13 2018 1,353 Resale 1524 Bent Willow Dr $175,000 $147 2025-12-29 1991 1,194 Resale 4123 Stag Run Ct $226,600 $185 2025-10-24 1993 1,228 Resale 4082 Cottage Wood Trl $215,000 $175 2025-09-12 1987 1,228 Resale 1555 Sprucewood Trl $166,000 $165 2025-09-12 1988 1,007 Resale 1553 Cinnamon Bear Cir $232,600 $189 2025-07-30 1988 1,228 Resale 4130 White Pine Ct $257,000 $209 2025-07-03 1989 1,228 Resale 1533 Cinnamon Bear Cir $254,900 $201 2025-06-17 1989 1,268 Resale 4252 Red Oak Dr $222,000 $220 2025-05-01 1988 1,010 Resale 1510 Grey Fox Run $235,000 $191 2025-04-29 1994 1,228 Resale 1537 Cinnamon Bear Cir $236,500 $193 2025-03-28 1988 1,228 Resale 4147 Cottage Wood Trl $238,000 $198 2025-03-10 1987 1,203 Resale 4212 Red Oak Dr $239,000 $195 2025-02-14 1988 1,228 Resale 1552 Cinnamon Bear Cir $235,000 $167 2024-12-31 1988 1,408 Resale 1556 Cinnamon Bear Cir $205,000 $200 2024-12-06 1989 1,023 Resale 4134 White Pine Ct $235,000 $205 2024-11-18 1989 1,147 Resale 4169 Laurel Oak Cir $205,000 $167 2024-09-26 1994 1,228 Resale 1561 Cinnamon Bear Cir $249,000 $196 2024-09-13 1987 1,268 Resale 1500 Bent Willow Dr $235,000 $206 2024-09-03 1989 1,140 Resale 1467 Grey Fox Run $192,500 $151 2024-08-02 1996 1,272 Resale 1479 Bent Willow Dr $259,000 $211 2024-07-31 1988 1,228 Resale 1464 Bent Willow Dr $239,000 $197 2024-07-12 1990 1,214 Resale 4041 Cottage Wood Trl $250,000 $223 2024-06-18 1988 1,123 Resale 1470 Grey Fox Run $206,000 $205 2024-05-31 1994 1,007 Resale 1554 Sprucewood Trl $199,400 $198 2024-05-17 1988 1,007 Resale 4244 Red Oak Dr $245,000 $204 2024-05-10 1989 1,203 Resale 4236 Red Oak Dr $269,900 $220 2024-04-24 1989 1,228 Resale 1560 Cinnamon Bear Cir $242,500 $198 2024-02-19 1991 1,226 Resale 4188 Red Oak Dr $190,000 $152 2023-12-04 1993 1,249 Resale 4095 Cottage Wood Trl $290,000 $239 2023-11-22 1988 1,214 Resale 1564 Sprucewood Trl $259,900 $212 2023-08-31 1988 1,228 Resale 4134 Cottage Wood Trl $259,000 $213 2023-08-01 1988 1,216 Resale 1474 Grey Fox Run $103,000 $88 2023-07-20 1996 1,166 Resale 4146 Laurel Oak Cir $233,000 $200 2023-06-20 1993 1,166 Resale 4131 Laurel Oak Cir $130,000 $108 2023-06-09 1988 1,200 Resale 4046 Cottage Wood Trl $255,000 $210 2023-05-31 1989 1,214 Resale 4131 Stag Run Ct $225,000 $191 2023-04-28 1990 1,181 Resale 1451 Grey Fox Run $245,000 $196 2023-03-09 1987 1,248 Resale 4034 Cottage Wood Trl $230,000 $189 2023-01-17 1990 1,214 Resale 4142 White Pine Ct $225,000 $185 2023-01-06 1989 1,214 Resale 1564 Sprucewood Trl $244,500 $199 2022-12-12 1988 1,228 Resale 4098 Cottage Wood Trl $216,000 $176 2022-11-03 1988 1,228 Resale 4090 Cottage Wood Trl $230,000 $191 2022-10-20 1988 1,204 Resale 1483 Bent Willow Dr $220,000 $153 2022-10-07 1988 1,437 Resale 4122 White Pine Ct $225,000 $183 2022-09-19 1990 1,228 Resale 4050 Cottage Wood Trl $219,000 $217 2022-09-12 1989 1,007 Resale 4126 Cottage Wood Trl $227,000 $187 2022-09-06 1989 1,214 Resale 1483 Grey Fox Run $220,000 $200 2022-07-29 1993 1,098 Resale 1521 Cinnamon Bear Cir $205,000 $167 2022-06-30 1989 1,228 Resale 4150 Laurel Oak Cir $235,000 $202 2022-06-16 1994 1,166 Resale 1468 Grey Fox Run $217,000 $177 2022-06-15 1995 1,223 Resale 4120 Red Cedar Ct $225,000 $185 2022-05-27 1989 1,214 Resale 1479 Bent Willow Dr $215,000 $175 2022-05-27 1988 1,228 Resale 4134 White Pine Ct $215,000 $187 2022-05-17 1989 1,147 Resale 4112 Red Cedar Ct $210,000 $171 2022-03-29 1989 1,228 Resale 4171 Red Oak Dr $240,500 $154 2022-03-11 1994 1,558 Resale 1553 Cinnamon Bear Cir $221,000 $180 2022-03-04 1988 1,228 Resale 1515 Grey Fox Run $227,400 $155 2022-01-26 1990 1,469 Resale 4208 Red Oak Dr $205,000 $167 2021-11-03 1988 1,228 Resale 4082 Cottage Wood Trl $185,100 $151 2021-09-17 1987 1,228 Resale 1496 Bent Willow Dr $215,000 $175 2021-09-15 1989 1,228 Resale 4130 White Pine Ct $202,500 $165 2021-08-06 1989 1,228 Resale 1547 Sprucewood Trl $190,000 $154 2021-07-30 1990 1,232 Resale 1562 Sprucewood Trl $170,000 $169 2021-07-28 1988 1,007 Resale 4178 Laurel Oak Cir $205,000 $150 2021-07-07 1993 1,364 Resale 1581 Cinnamon Bear Cir $193,500 $145 2021-06-23 1987 1,337 Resale 4126 Cottage Wood Trl $175,000 $144 2021-05-05 1989 1,214 Resale 1495 Grey Fox Run $190,000 $164 2021-05-03 1995 1,160 Resale 1504 Bent Willow Dr $180,000 $154 2021-04-23 1989 1,170 Resale 1552 Cinnamon Bear Cir $183,000 $130 2021-04-09 1988 1,408 Resale 1502 Grey Fox Run $175,000 $146 2021-03-30 1996 1,201 Resale 4109 Red Cedar Ct $163,400 $162 2021-03-10 1989 1,007 Resale 4244 Red Oak Dr $177,000 $147 2021-03-10 1989 1,203 Resale 4200 Red Oak Dr $185,000 $168 2021-03-05 1993 1,098 Resale 4119 Sugar Bear Dr $135,000 $134 2021-02-16 1988 1,007 Resale 4204 Red Oak Dr $167,000 $136 2021-02-16 1994 1,228 Resale 4127 White Pine Ct $171,000 $142 2021-02-11 1989 1,200 Resale 1460 Bent Willow Dr $165,000 $136 2021-01-19 1986 1,214 Resale 1520 Bent Willow Dr $171,000 $146 2021-01-15 1989 1,168 Resale 1463 Grey Fox Run $168,400 $137 2020-11-10 1997 1,228 Resale 4123 White Pine Ct $169,000 $138 2020-10-09 1988 1,228 Resale 1459 Grey Fox Run $182,500 $147 2020-09-30 1994 1,240 Resale 4133 Red Cedar Ct $146,500 $145 2020-09-08 1989 1,007 Resale 4220 Red Oak Dr $166,500 $148 2020-09-04 1989 1,122 Resale 4122 Cottage Wood Trl $164,000 $125 2020-09-03 1987 1,316 Resale 4173 Laurel Oak Cir $184,500 $150 2020-09-01 1994 1,228 Resale 1464 Bent Willow Dr $173,000 $143 2020-07-31 1990 1,214 Resale 4142 Cottage Wood Trl $170,000 $138 2020-07-24 1990 1,228 Resale 4042 Cottage Wood Trl $140,000 $114 2020-07-17 1988 1,228 Resale 4173 Laurel Oak Cir $132,500 $108 2020-06-19 1994 1,228 Resale 4123 Stag Run Ct $171,000 $139 2020-06-12 1993 1,228 Resale 4137 Red Cedar Ct $171,000 $138 2020-06-04 1987 1,242 Resale 1537 Cinnamon Bear Cir $175,000 $143 2020-05-15 1988 1,228 Resale 4187 Red Oak Dr $169,000 $135 2020-05-06 1994 1,254 Resale
Great Tips For Buying A Home
Buy Now Or Wait? The 91.6% Rule
Biased Results? The New York Times Rent Or Buy Calculator
Do's And Don'ts During The Home Loan Process
6 Real Estate Contract Terms You Should Not Overlook
7 Tips On Buying A Home With A Pool
How much house can you actually afford (By Income)?
What Does "Marry The House Date The Rate" Mean In Real Estate?
Why Fixer Uppers Are the New Gold | Home Renovation Guide
8 Tips For Buying An Affordable Florida Vacation Home
Thousands of Joe Manausa Team customers have left reviews on Google, Facebook, and Zillow. Read the Tallahassee real estate agent reviews.
