Settlers Creek is a popular NW Tallahassee neighborhood containing a mix of 300 detached and attached single-family four, three, and two-bedroom homes.
Located west of Old Bainbridge Road and south of Fred George Road, residents here enjoy quick and easy access to downtown Tallahassee.
Settlers Creek Homes for Sale
Settlers Creek Schools
Settlers Creek is zoned for the following Leon County public schools:
This Settlers Creek neighborhood report includes charts and graphs that display average home prices, home values, and home sizes, as well as a list of the most recent closed home sales in Settlers Creek.
For each of the three real estate graphs found in this Tallahassee housing report, you will find the number of closed home sales for each year (red columns, measured on the left vertical axis), and an important real estate statistic shown in blue (measured on the right vertical axis).
The graphs and the closed sales table will be continuously updated into the future (meaning bookmark this page if you always want to know the current status of homes in Settlers Creek).
Settlers Creek Home Prices
The average price of the homes sold in Settlers Creek actually fell in 2021! Does that mean nobody wants to live here? Are prices and values falling?
Average Home Price
Actually, there is nothing wrong in Settlers Creek. Activity in Settlers Creek is strong, with low inventory throughout the entire Tallahassee market coupled with low mortgage interest rates have buyers wanting homes. The reason the average price fell was the a higher percentage of attached homes sold this year than what normally occurs. You can tell from the next two charts that all is good in Settlers Creek.
Currently, there is just one home for sale in Settlers Creek and it is already under contract with a buyer.
Home Values In Settlers Creek
The average home value in Settlers Creek has risen more than 12% in 2021 after rising 10% in 2020. Needless to say, homes values in Settlers Creek are soaring!
Average Home Value
The average home value in Settlers Creek in 2021 is $134 per square foot.
Settlers Creek Home Sizes
The average size of homes sold in Settlers Creek typically falls within a range of 1,150 to 1,400 square feet, but 2021 set a record for the smallest average ever recorded in a single year.
Average Home Size
The 17 homes sold in 2021 were measured at an average size of 1,136 square feet.
Recent Home Sales In Settlers Creek
The following list shows the most recent 1,000 home sales in Settlers Creek since 1991. Note that you can reorganize the list by simply clicking the column heading for the data you wish to sort by.
Home Sales in Settlers CreekAddress Price Price / SQF Closing Date Year Built SQF Sale Type 3154 S Fulmer Cir $272,000 $179 2026-06-26 1994 1,521 Resale 3853 Magellan Ct $281,000 $186 2026-06-12 1992 1,508 Resale 3906 Gaffney Loop $159,900 $162 2026-03-19 1993 984 Resale 3114 Mccord Blvd $270,000 $198 2026-03-12 1994 1,366 Resale 3182 S Fulmer Cir $280,000 $202 2025-12-30 1994 1,386 Resale 3092 S Fulmer Cir $285,000 $193 2025-09-12 1995 1,476 Resale 3885 Gaffney Loop $165,000 $161 2025-08-29 1994 1,026 Resale 3918 Gaffney Loop $138,000 $140 2025-08-25 1993 984 Resale 3158 S Fulmer Cir $270,000 $184 2025-08-18 1993 1,467 Resale 3969 Gaffney Loop $173,900 $177 2025-06-27 1992 984 Resale 3182 S Fulmer Cir $280,500 $202 2025-06-25 1994 1,386 Resale 3996 Gaffney Loop $174,000 $173 2025-06-16 1992 1,006 Resale 3194 S Fulmer Cir $175,000 $173 2025-02-28 1993 1,014 Resale 3033 N Fulmer Cir $285,000 $194 2025-02-27 1993 1,466 Resale 3129 Hotchkiss Ln $185,000 $188 2025-01-15 1993 984 Resale 3985 Gaffney Loop $152,500 $155 2025-01-07 1992 984 Resale 3978 Gaffney Loop $175,000 $178 2024-10-18 1992 984 Resale 3135 Hotchkiss Ln $180,000 $183 2024-07-10 1993 984 Resale 3153 S Fulmer Cir $242,000 $179 2024-05-20 1993 1,353 Resale 3896 Gaffney Loop $170,000 $173 2024-04-15 1993 984 Resale 3979 Gaffney Loop $175,000 $178 2024-03-26 1992 984 Resale 3900 Mayflower Ct $285,000 $172 2024-02-09 1989 1,655 Resale 3063 Mccord Blvd $250,000 $136 2024-01-23 1990 1,842 Resale 3015 Mccord Blvd $265,000 $180 2023-12-28 1991 1,475 Resale 3908 Gaffney Loop $160,000 $163 2023-12-20 1993 984 Resale 3971 Gaffney Loop $170,000 $169 2023-12-11 1992 1,008 Resale 3938 Gaffney Loop $162,000 $165 2023-11-17 1992 984 Resale 3116 Hotchkiss Ln $175,000 $178 2023-11-16 1994 984 Resale 3011 Mccord Blvd $245,000 $141 2023-11-09 1990 1,740 Resale 3963 Magellan Trl $265,000 $170 2023-11-03 1989 1,558 Resale 3884 Gaffney Loop $195,000 $155 2023-10-31 1994 1,256 Resale 3028 N Fulmer Cir $257,000 $186 2023-07-20 1991 1,382 Resale 3896 Mayflower Ct $336,500 $225 2023-07-17 1990 1,494 Resale 3024 N Fulmer Cir $271,000 $194 2023-07-06 1993 1,396 Resale 3844 Magellan Ct $299,000 $167 2023-04-28 1991 1,794 Resale 3145 S Fulmer Cir $257,900 $181 2023-01-27 1994 1,424 Resale 3890 Gaffney Loop $165,000 $168 2023-01-20 1994 984 Resale 3162 S Fulmer Cir $268,000 $156 2022-12-16 1993 1,719 Resale 3921 Gaffney Loop $145,000 $147 2022-12-16 1992 984 Resale 3981 Gaffney Loop $154,000 $157 2022-11-22 1992 984 Resale 3940 Gaffney Loop $170,000 $173 2022-11-10 1992 984 Resale 3982 Gaffney Loop $143,400 $146 2022-10-28 1992 984 Resale 3105 Hotchkiss Ln $143,000 $145 2022-10-03 1992 984 Resale 3852 Magellan Ct $319,000 $206 2022-09-13 1996 1,552 Resale 3920 Gaffney Loop $139,000 $141 2022-08-12 1993 984 Resale 3959 Gaffney Loop $150,000 $152 2022-08-12 1992 984 Resale 3104 Hotchkiss Ln $165,000 $168 2022-08-04 1993 984 Resale 3896 Mayflower Ct $289,000 $193 2022-07-19 1990 1,494 Resale 3071 Mccord Blvd $238,000 $146 2022-06-06 1990 1,628 Resale 3064 N Fulmer Cir $255,000 $179 2022-06-02 1992 1,422 Resale 3894 Gaffney Loop $139,000 $141 2022-05-20 1993 984 Resale 3185 S Fulmer Cir $250,000 $184 2022-05-11 1992 1,359 Resale 3112 S Fulmer Cir $252,000 $186 2022-04-01 1994 1,358 Resale 3956 Gaffney Loop $160,000 $163 2022-03-31 1992 984 Resale 3954 Gaffney Loop $176,000 $179 2022-03-21 1992 984 Resale 3840 Magellan Ct $208,000 $131 2022-03-16 1994 1,586 Resale 3993 Columbus Ct $277,500 $193 2022-03-14 1990 1,438 Resale 3120 S Fulmer Cir $250,900 $169 2022-03-04 1993 1,484 Resale 3979 Gaffney Loop $100,000 $102 2022-02-25 1992 984 Resale 3878 Gaffney Loop $124,000 $126 2022-02-14 1994 984 Resale 3883 Magellan Trl $210,000 $196 2022-01-24 1992 1,072 Resale 3886 Gaffney Loop $125,900 $128 2021-12-20 1994 984 Resale 3061 N Fulmer Cir $225,000 $151 2021-12-10 1992 1,488 Resale 3019 Mccord Blvd $227,500 $196 2021-11-30 1992 1,161 Resale 3909 Gaffney Loop $118,000 $120 2021-11-23 1994 984 Resale 3982 Gaffney Loop $105,000 $107 2021-11-01 1992 984 Resale 3906 Gaffney Loop $123,400 $125 2021-10-05 1993 984 Resale 3848 Magellan Ct $197,000 $141 2021-10-02 1991 1,398 Resale 3116 Hotchkiss Ln $122,000 $124 2021-09-24 1994 984 Resale 3067 Mccord Blvd $209,000 $155 2021-09-17 1992 1,352 Resale 3873 Gaffney Loop $113,000 $115 2021-09-03 1993 984 Resale 3048 N Fulmer Cir $230,000 $182 2021-07-30 1992 1,261 Resale 3876 Gaffney Loop $114,000 $116 2021-07-30 1994 984 Resale 3917 Gaffney Loop $123,000 $125 2021-07-16 1992 984 Resale 3918 Gaffney Loop $118,000 $120 2021-07-08 1993 984 Resale 3024 N Fulmer Cir $218,200 $156 2021-06-30 1993 1,396 Resale 3141 S Fulmer Cir $187,500 $151 2021-04-13 1993 1,244 Resale 3135 Hotchkiss Ln $118,000 $120 2021-01-25 1993 984 Resale 3108 Mccord Blvd $190,000 $127 2021-01-22 1993 1,500 Resale 3963 Gaffney Loop $112,000 $114 2021-01-20 1992 984 Resale 3149 S Fulmer Cir $202,000 $144 2020-12-15 1992 1,406 Resale 3914 Gaffney Loop $110,000 $112 2020-12-04 1993 984 Resale 3958 Gaffney Loop $106,300 $108 2020-11-30 1992 984 Resale 3057 N Fulmer Cir $206,500 $115 2020-11-06 1992 1,793 Resale 3158 S Fulmer Cir $185,000 $126 2020-10-09 1993 1,467 Resale 3971 Gaffney Loop $99,000 $98 2020-10-09 1992 1,008 Resale 3103 Mccord Blvd $170,000 $125 2020-09-30 1994 1,358 Resale 3130 Hotchkiss Ln $117,000 $119 2020-09-30 1994 984 Resale 3852 Magellan Ct $221,500 $143 2020-08-20 1996 1,552 Resale 3182 S Fulmer Cir $154,500 $111 2020-07-30 1994 1,386 Resale 3049 Laredo Dr $221,200 $148 2020-06-18 1990 1,498 Resale 3925 Gaffney Loop $99,500 $101 2020-05-22 1992 984 Resale 3023 N Fulmer Cir $215,000 $127 2020-04-30 1993 1,698 Resale 3132 Hotchkiss Ln $106,700 $108 2020-04-27 1994 984 Resale 3162 S Fulmer Cir $199,900 $116 2020-04-22 1993 1,719 Resale 3165 S Fulmer Cir $164,000 $135 2020-04-17 1993 1,219 Resale 3950 Magellan Trl $168,300 $148 2020-04-03 1990 1,141 Resale 3885 Gaffney Loop $99,000 $96 2020-04-02 1994 1,026 Resale 3112 S Fulmer Cir $190,000 $140 2020-03-31 1994 1,358 Resale 3154 S Fulmer Cir $174,500 $115 2020-03-31 1994 1,521 Resale
Great Video Tips For Homebuyers
Buy Now Or Wait? The 91.6% Rule
Biased Results? The New York Times Rent Or Buy Calculator
Do's And Don'ts During The Home Loan Process
6 Real Estate Contract Terms You Should Not Overlook
7 Tips On Buying A Home With A Pool
How much house can you actually afford (By Income)?
What Does "Marry The House Date The Rate" Mean In Real Estate?
Why Fixer Uppers Are the New Gold | Home Renovation Guide
8 Tips For Buying An Affordable Florida Vacation Home
Thousands of Joe Manausa Team customers have left reviews on Google, Facebook, and Zillow. Read the Tallahassee real estate agent reviews.
