Back to Blog Posts

Which Are The Top Appreciating Neighborhoods In Tallahassee?

Posted by
Share
Share
Share
Share

A spotlight of the fastest appreciating neighborhoods in TallahasseeWhether you own a home in Tallahassee and are curious or you are actively in the market to buy a home, it’s important to know what home values are doing.

Today’s report is short and sweet, and it serves to spotlight the fastest appreciating neighborhoods in Tallahassee. First, it starts with a list of all homes for sale in Tallahassee and then concludes with graphs, analysis, and a table of the most recent home sales in Tallahassee’s top neighborhoods.

Homes For Sale In Tallahassee Neighborhoods

Tallahassee Homes for Sale

Get AlertsRefine Results
1,301 Properties
Page 1 of 21
52
4434 AMBER VALLEY Road , Tallahassee, FL, 32312
Active Under Contract
$400,000
4434 AMBER VALLEY Road
Tallahassee, FL, 32312
Beds3Baths2MLS#406263
Open House
42
3037 Corrib Drive , Tallahassee, FL, 32309
Active
$399,000
3037 Corrib Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32309
Beds4Baths3MLS#406261
1
1638 Sharkey Street , Tallahassee, FL, 32304
Active
$155,000
1638 Sharkey Street
Tallahassee, FL, 32304
Beds3Baths1MLS#406252
53
1013 SAN LUIS Road , Tallahassee, FL, 32304
Active
$309,000
1013 SAN LUIS Road
Tallahassee, FL, 32304
Beds4Baths2MLS#406251
19
710 N Gadsden 11, Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Active Under Contract
$175,000
710 N Gadsden 11
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds2Baths2MLS#406249
39
1132 Camellia Drive , Tallahassee, FL, 32301
Active Under Contract
$365,000
1132 Camellia Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32301
Beds4Baths2MLS#406247
49
4545 Wesley Drive , Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Active
$234,000
4545 Wesley Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#406246
30
3091 SHAMROCK N Street , Tallahassee, FL, 32309
Active
$564,290
3091 SHAMROCK N Street
Tallahassee, FL, 32309
Beds3Baths2MLS#406241
32
1501 Meeks Road , Tallahassee, FL, 32317
Active
$309,700
1501 Meeks Road
Tallahassee, FL, 32317
Beds3Baths3MLS#406240
36
1621 San Damian Road , Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Active
$520,000
1621 San Damian Road
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths3MLS#406238
Open House
50
2992 Cranbrooke Drive , Tallahassee, FL, 32309
Active
$389,000
2992 Cranbrooke Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32309
Beds3Baths2MLS#406236
70
117 MEADOW WOOD Court , Tallahassee, FL, 32312
Active
$1,895,000
117 MEADOW WOOD Court
Tallahassee, FL, 32312
Beds4Baths4MLS#406235
...

Tallahassee Fastest Appreciating Neighborhoods Since 2017

Rather than just look at eight months of data, I went back to the start of 2017 and pulled all neighborhoods selling at least two homes each month for this report. The graph below shows the top appreciating Tallahassee neighborhoods, arranged from the bottom to the top.

Tallahassee neighborhoods with the highest value appreciation rate

Forest Heights is the fastest appreciating neighborhood for the past 3.7 years, with values moving 52% during that period of time. That’s an annualized growth rate of 12%, which is roughly 4 times the historic norm.

Graphs like the one above can be a great tool for buyers, looking to find a neighborhood that has not kept up with the market. Of course, it’s not merely as simple as choosing one from the top, you have to understand some of the other issues impacting value growth.

For example, Canopy at the very top, is a new neighborhood and most of its sales are new construction homes, so we’re not going to see values move as high as in neighborhoods (like Camelot Park) which only post existing home sales.

This is a great topic to discuss with your real estate buyers’ agent if you have not yet decided where you would like to live.

Buying here? Talk to a buyer's agent first.

A Joe Manausa Team member on your side before you fall for a house. Leave your name and email and we will reach out.

Long-Term Value Growth Leaders

The following graph shows the same group of neighborhoods as before, but this time we plot growth since the bottom of the housing market in 2012 when most neighborhoods posted the lowest home values since well before the housing bubble exploded.

Tallahassee neighborhood home value growth since the bottom of the housing market in 2012

Forest Heights is no longer the top performer, but it still has an impressive growth exceeding 70% since 2012. The fastest appreciating neighborhood during the past nine years is Timber Lake coming in at a whopping 96% appreciating, with its homes nearly doubling in value since 2012. That’s an annual growth rate of more than eight percent!

Some neighborhoods were hit harder by the housing market collapse, so that can be a reason why some have further recovered than have others. If you are looking to find a diamond in the rough, you’ll want to remove as many variables as possible when attempting to find a neighborhood poised to beat the market. Of course, working with a highly regarded, experienced buyers’ agent can help you in this regard.

Recent Home Sales In Tallahassee

The following table shows the most recent 1,000 home sales in Tallahassee’s top-selling neighborhoods. You can sort the table by any field in the header (including neighborhood). Enjoy!

Top 24% of all existing home sales in Tallahassee in 2020

NeighborhoodAddressPricePrice / SQFClosing DateYear BuiltSQF
Killearn Estates4034 Delvin Dr$379,000$2182026-10-0919731,740
Golden Eagle Plantation2316 Cobb Dr$615,000$1982026-10-0920003,104
Killearn Acres6429 Jet Pilot Trl$260,200$1512026-10-0919861,718
Killearn Estates3113 Shannon Lakes N$455,000$2052026-10-0519862,222
Killearn Acres6704 Johnstown Loop$340,000$1802026-10-0219841,888
Killearn Acres6708 Chant Trl$335,000$2422026-10-0219791,386
Killearn Estates2933 Tipperary Ct$395,000$2062026-10-0119711,921
Killearn Estates2348 Ryan Pl$215,000$1812026-09-3019831,188
Goose Creek201 Myddelton Trce$430,000$2432026-09-3020021,766
Killearn Acres6842 Donerail Trl$295,000$2352026-09-3019811,253
Southwood2545 Lantana Ln$525,000$2462026-09-3020162,137
Killearn Acres3257 Lord Murphy Trl$270,000$1492026-09-2919891,815
Killearn Estates4019 Kilmartin Dr$435,000$2042026-09-2819872,132
Golden Eagle Plantation8503 Congressional Dr$1,700,000$2442026-09-2820016,960
Southwood3179 Nathaniel Trce$491,000$2522026-09-2820131,946
Golden Eagle Plantation2998 Golden Eagle Dr E$1,375,000$2192026-09-2519956,280
Lakeshore Estates3420 Monitor Ln$350,000$2262026-09-2519801,546
Killearn Estates3005 Tipperary Dr$325,000$2202026-09-2419691,478
Southwood3158 Coneflower Dr$330,000$2362026-09-2320091,400
Forest Heights1901 Sherwood Dr$269,000$1352026-09-2219651,989
Forest Heights1905 Rosedale Dr$335,000$1502026-09-2119542,230
Southwood3248 Appleton Dr$540,000$1812026-09-2120062,983
Piney Z1039 Winter Ln$350,000$2352026-09-1820011,492
Piney Z780 Eagle View Dr$424,500$2062026-09-1820032,059
Killearn Acres3335 Gallant Fox Trl$325,000$2202026-09-1819841,480
Southwood3686 Longfellow Rd$470,000$1982026-09-1820042,379
Golden Eagle Plantation8893 Saltcoates Ct$569,000$2432026-09-1519942,338
Killearn Estates3708 Galway Dr$317,000$1172026-09-1119712,702
Piney Z4878 Planters Ridge Dr$345,000$2252026-09-1020021,533
Killearn Acres3208 Majestic Prince Trl$355,000$2542026-09-1019901,397
Killearn Acres4983 Pimlico Dr$327,800$1982026-09-1019881,653
Indian Head Acres1606 Wekewa Nene$295,000$2072026-09-1019581,422
Piney Z4882 Heritage Park Blvd$369,000$2152026-09-0920021,716
Golden Eagle Plantation9022 Winged Foot Dr$495,000$1812026-09-0419882,740
Ox Bottom Manor6408 Mallard Trace Dr$515,000$2202026-09-0319992,340
Southwood2496 Mount Vernon Ln$475,000$2162026-09-0320222,195
Southwood2496 Lantana Ln$599,900$1822026-09-0320073,289
Southwood3147 Mulberry Park Blvd$299,000$2022026-09-0320021,483
Southwood4370 Grove Park Dr Unit 1$420,000$2142026-09-0320051,962
Forest Heights1408 W Tharpe St$272,000$1342026-09-0220072,027
Killearn Estates3750 Shamrock W$499,900$2262026-09-0119722,214
Killearn Estates3175 Ferns Glen Dr$550,000$1682026-08-3119793,268
Golden Eagle Plantation2868 Royal Isle Dr$852,000$2872026-08-3120032,968
Killearn Acres6705 Tim Tam Trl$325,000$1882026-08-3119831,726
Southwood3146 Duxbury Ln$725,000$2052026-08-3120083,541
Killearn Estates3510 Tullamore Ln$380,000$1502026-08-2819722,539
Piney Z1031 Landings Loop$296,000$2142026-08-2820011,385
Goose Creek167 Leah Martin Ct$340,000$2082026-08-2820021,637
Golden Eagle Plantation8836 Winged Foot Dr$1,325,000$3232026-08-2819954,100
Ox Bottom Manor6394 Belgrand Dr$815,000$2402026-08-2819963,389
Southwood3242 Stanhope Dr$567,000$2272026-08-2820032,495
Killearn Estates3904 Shamrock W$584,900$2402026-08-2719752,433
Killearn Estates3301 Clifden Dr$450,000$1542026-08-2619872,922
Summerbrooke1443 Conservancy Dr E$589,000$2742026-08-2620032,153
Lakeshore Estates209 Ridgeland Rd$535,900$1752026-08-2619723,069
Southwood2512 Goldenrod Way$514,900$2492026-08-2620142,068
Killearn Estates4133 Arklow Dr$370,000$1942026-08-2419731,905
Piney Z912 Park View Dr$485,000$1762026-08-2120022,752
Southwood2421 Orange Ave E$435,000$1992026-08-2120102,181
Golden Eagle Plantation8983 Winged Foot Dr$1,125,000$2672026-08-2019894,213
Killearn Estates2317 Limerick Dr$490,000$1602026-08-1919673,056
Summerbrooke1205 Wax Wing Ct$640,000$2312026-08-1920012,775
Golden Eagle Plantation2685 Wharton Cir$560,000$1942026-08-1820002,893
Golden Eagle Plantation2520 Double Eagle Ct$795,000$2342026-08-1420023,400
Killearn Acres6838 Hill Gail Trl$345,000$2562026-08-1419871,349
Killearn Estates3133 Tipperary Dr$360,000$2072026-08-1019691,741
Southwood3976 Shumard Oak Blvd$260,000$1962026-08-0520051,324
Golden Eagle Plantation9270 Shoal Creek Dr$975,000$3232026-08-0420163,023
Golden Eagle Plantation8991 Winged Foot Dr$1,050,000$2042026-08-0419875,135
Killearn Acres6515 Man O War Trl$319,300$2652026-08-0419871,205
Killearn Estates2805 Tipperary Dr$365,000$2152026-07-3119711,700
Piney Z1173 Winter Ln$355,000$2212026-07-3120011,605
Summerbrooke7521 Refuge Rd$621,300$2022026-07-3119933,074
Ox Bottom Manor371 Milestone Dr$485,000$1972026-07-3119932,463
Killearn Acres3201 Whirlaway Trl$300,000$2022026-07-3119791,486
Killearn Acres6516 Montrose Trl$305,000$2082026-07-3119831,465
Indian Head Acres2019 E Indian Head Dr$297,000$1822026-07-3119561,632
Killearn Estates3721 Longford Dr$530,000$2122026-07-3019752,495
Killearn Acres6842 Donerail Trl$190,000$1522026-07-3019811,253
Summerbrooke916 Hill Roost Rd$577,000$2062026-07-2919922,807
Killearn Acres3516 Whirlaway Trl$395,000$2052026-07-2919891,924
Killearn Estates3056 Corrib Dr$420,000$2212026-07-2819691,902
Summerbrooke7588 Preservation Rd$510,000$2092026-07-2820032,443
Ox Bottom Manor6274 Hines Hill Cir$750,000$2812026-07-2819932,668
Southwood3121 Mulberry Park Blvd$350,000$2012026-07-2820021,744
Lakeshore Estates3355 Argonaut Dr$240,000$1972026-07-2419991,221
Killearn Estates4032 Ardara Dr$400,000$2132026-07-2319741,877
Goose Creek224 Myddelton Trce$354,000$1782026-07-2120051,986
Lakeshore Estates265 Timberlane Rd$357,000$1892026-07-2119811,885
Southwood2130 Fielding Way$415,000$1452026-07-2020032,869
Killearn Estates2524 Limerick Dr$403,000$2312026-07-1719701,745
Golden Eagle Plantation9132 Shoal Creek Dr$720,000$2112026-07-1619973,420
Killearn Acres6728 Apollo Trl$180,000$1122026-07-1619791,610
Southwood3780 Longfellow Rd$685,000$2702026-07-1620112,539
Summerbrooke7096 Spicewood Ln$622,500$2292026-07-1520002,724
Southwood2133 Drayton Dr$542,000$2012026-07-1320022,691
Killearn Estates3194 Ferns Glen Dr$300,000$1332026-07-1019882,251
Ox Bottom Manor344 Meadow Ridge Dr$525,000$2772026-07-1019941,897
Killearn Estates3726 Wicklow Cir$430,000$1642026-07-0819782,615
Ox Bottom Manor6309 Coach House Ct$548,000$2242026-07-0819922,443

Important Information For Homebuyers In 2021

Thousands of Joe Manausa Team customers have left reviews on Google, Facebook, and Zillow. Read the Tallahassee real estate agent reviews.

5.0 on Google from 909 reviews

Ready to talk to a local expert?

Moving to, within, or from Tallahassee, a Joe Manausa Team member gives you the local answers a smooth transaction needs.

Send Us A Note Call (850) 366-8917

Related Posts