Tallahassee Neighborhoods With The Highest Appreciation Rates

Last updated: September 29, 2026

Posted by
Share
Share
Share
Share

I was being interviewed by TaMaryn Waters at the Tallahassee Democrat the other day when the topic of real estate appreciation came up.

I mentioned to her that there were several neighborhoods on pace to appeciate at more than 10% this year, due to the high demand for homes combined with historic low inventories.

Due to her surprise, I realized this would make for a great report, so I have included all neighborhoods in Tallahassee that have had ten home sales or more thus far in 2018 which are on track to post (or long surpassed) appreciation rates above 10%.

Here is a list of homes for sale in these neighborhoods, followed by a graph and report of the top performers.

Homes For Sale In High Appreciating Neighborhoods

2018 Highest Appreciating Neighborhoods Homes For Sale

22 Properties
Page 1 of 2
2738 W Tharpe Street 802
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths3MLS#403108
4695 Autumn Woods Way
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2SqFt910MLS#398957
3691 WOOD HILL DRIVE Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#406749
1734 W Tharpe Street
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#405779
3529 Wood Hill Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#402896
1402 W Tharpe Street
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths1MLS#405112
4020 Elder Lane
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#406518
1918 BOTANY Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds4Baths3MLS#399668
2421 Lola Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32301
Beds3Baths2MLS#406110
1313 Lehigh Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32301
Beds3Baths2MLS#404747
1730 W Tharpe Street
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds4Baths2MLS#401317
6451 Cavalcade Trail
Tallahassee, FL, 32309
Beds3Baths2MLS#405353

Real Estate Appreciation 101

When you combine scarcity with high demand, you get appreciation. This is true in any market, not just real estate.

Currently, the supply of homes for sale for more than 75% of our entire market area and price ranges falls too short to meet the current demand by prospective buyers. In fact, the inventory is so low that we’re seeing it impact the market by slowing down the recovery.

What Tallahassee needs is for more residential units to be built in or near the highest demand areas and price ranges. Specifically, we need more homes priced below $300,000, so consider this a call to all builders and developers to put together plans to bring attached and mutlifamily housing to our market, it will get consumed!

High Appreciating, High Selling Neighborhoods

For the purpose of this report, I have only included neighborhoods that have posted at least ten home sales thus far in 2018, as this is likely enough data to confirm appreciation rate growth.

all neighborhoods in Tallahassee that have had ten home sales or more thus far in 2018 which are on track to post (or long surpassed) appreciation rates above 10%.

The graph above shows appreciation rates (red line, recorded on the right vertical axis) and the number of homes sold in 2018 (blue bars, recorded on the left vertical axis).

Lafayette Oaks is leading the pack with an average growth rate of 23.2% with ten homes sold. Close behind with 16 homes sold and an equally impressive growth rate of 21.1% is Plantation Woods. The lowest on the list is Forest Heights which has posted 16 home sales and has already reached 10.0% (through mid July).

When the year is said and done, there will likely be more than 20 neighborhoods with ten or more sales and better than a 10% rate of appreciation, which is incredible.

Right now, all existing home sales have an average rate of growth of 5.7%, which is an annualized rate of 8.4%, well more than double an average year (going back to 1991). Existing homes in Tallahassee are appreciating, now is a great time to own a home.

Worried About A Bubble?

Anybody who lived through the market swing from 2005 to 2012 is likely to read the information above and worry about another housing bubble.

I believe they should be worried, but not about a bubble any time soon. Actually, the opposite is what we need to be concerned with.

A housing bubble occurs when demand rises and causes builders to go into overdrive to meet that demand. One way to know a bubble is coming is to monitor the supply and demand dynamic (I publish a report on this monthly RIGHT HERE).

There is no chance of this coming about any time soon, short of a significant and severe depletion of jobs in Tallahassee. In fact, demand is still lower than it was during the pre-bubble years.

What’s different this time is that builders are not rising to meet the demand from homebuyers. Tallahassee is building at a level that is less than 50% the rate we saw in the 1990s, and only a quarter of the rate at which homes were built right before the bubble.

The Real Housing Market Dilemma

The problem Tallahassee is facing right now is low inventory, and that means we can expect crazy high levels of appreciation for years to come. If the jobs market grows as we expect with a new Governor next year, it will only make the inventory shortage greater.

If you have been wanting to buy a home, do it now. You will gain a lot of equity in the coming months and years, and it is possible that you might not be able to afford a home within a few years. If mortgage interest rates move higher, the more expensive home with even higher monthly payments could very well be beyond your reach.

As far as future bubbles, you are safe. Simply watch our monthly inventory reports, and if you see the market moving in the other direction (inventory levels rising above 6 months of supply), you will have plenty of time to sell your home at the top of the market.

Get Our Free Market Update

Weekly Special real estate report covers the Tallahassee real estate market

Other buyers, sellers, lenders, and real estate agents have this critical information, and now you can too!

Get immediate access to our most recent newsletter.

Let more than 30 years of experience work for you with charts, graphs, and analysis of the Tallahassee housing market.

Each Monday morning we send out a simple, one-page report that provides a snapshot of the Tallahassee housing market. It only takes 2 minutes to read, but it gives you better market intelligence than most real estate agents possess. Just tell us where to send it below!

Home Sales In Tallahassee’s Highest Appreciating Neighborhoods

The following table shows the most recent 1,000 sales in Tallahassee’s top appreciating neighborhoods. It’s important to note that you can sort the table by any column heading if you want to drill-down for more information.

Highest appreciating neighborhoods in Tallahassee

NeighborhoodAddressPricePrice / SQFClosing DateYear BuiltSQF
Killearn Acres6429 Jet Pilot Trl$260,200$1512026-10-0919861,718
Killearn Acres6704 Johnstown Loop$340,000$1802026-10-0219841,888
Killearn Acres6708 Chant Trl$335,000$2422026-10-0219791,386
Killearn Acres6842 Donerail Trl$295,000$2352026-09-3019811,253
Autumn Woods5752 Cypress Cir$208,000$1882026-09-3019791,104
Killearn Acres3257 Lord Murphy Trl$270,000$1492026-09-2919891,815
Betton Hills2607 Marston Rd$540,000$1692026-09-2319653,196
Forest Heights1901 Sherwood Dr$269,000$1352026-09-2219651,989
Forest Heights1905 Rosedale Dr$335,000$1502026-09-2119542,230
Killearn Acres3335 Gallant Fox Trl$325,000$2202026-09-1819841,480
Betton Hills2605 Armstrong Rd$595,000$2482026-09-1519752,402
Meadowbrook761 Lupine Ln$285,000$1902026-09-1119831,503
Killearn Acres3208 Majestic Prince Trl$355,000$2542026-09-1019901,397
Killearn Acres4983 Pimlico Dr$327,800$1982026-09-1019881,653
Forest Heights1408 W Tharpe St$272,000$1342026-09-0220072,027
Plantation Woods3591 Wood Hill Dr$215,000$2152026-09-0119801,002
Betton Hills1628 Woodgate Way$637,000$2492026-08-3119762,560
Killearn Acres6705 Tim Tam Trl$325,000$1882026-08-3119831,726
Betton Hills1579 Marion Ave$520,000$2532026-08-2719492,052
Savannah Crossing2738 W Tharpe St Apt 2505$128,000$1062026-08-2520041,209
Meadowbrook724 Red Fern Rd$314,000$2192026-08-2019841,434
Lafayette Oaks5150 Ile De France Dr$340,000$1452026-08-1919732,341
Meadowbrook799 Violet St$280,000$1402026-08-1919841,994
Betton Hills2503 Chamberlin Dr$453,000$1782026-08-1419722,540
Killearn Acres6838 Hill Gail Trl$345,000$2562026-08-1419871,349
Betton Hills2220 Armistead Rd$675,000$2242026-08-1019743,017
Lafayette Oaks2505 Napoleon Bonaparte Dr$415,000$2072026-08-0719852,004
Lafayette Oaks2400 Napoleon Bonaparte Dr$540,000$1572026-08-0719843,440
Plantation Woods4024 Elder Ln$252,500$2332026-08-0719821,084
Savannah Crossing2738 W Tharpe St Apt 804$143,200$1182026-08-0520041,209
Killearn Acres6515 Man O War Trl$319,300$2652026-08-0419871,205
Killearn Acres3201 Whirlaway Trl$300,000$2022026-07-3119791,486
Killearn Acres6516 Montrose Trl$305,000$2082026-07-3119831,465
Killearn Acres6842 Donerail Trl$190,000$1522026-07-3019811,253
Killearn Acres3516 Whirlaway Trl$395,000$2052026-07-2919891,924
Meadowbrook2430 Beautyberry Ct$365,000$2062026-07-2819961,776
Timber Lake4109 Red Cedar Ct$220,000$2182026-07-2819891,007
Betton Hills2125 Trescott Dr$640,000$2622026-07-2119812,444
Savannah Crossing2738 W Tharpe St Apt 1502$145,000$1202026-07-2120041,209
Killearn Acres6728 Apollo Trl$180,000$1122026-07-1619791,610
Timber Lake4102 Cottage Wood Trl$220,000$1792026-07-0219881,228
Plantation Woods4256 Carrington Ct$215,000$2232026-06-291980962
Killearn Acres6727 Johnstown Loop$314,000$2332026-06-2619861,347
Killearn Acres4891 Pimlico Dr$297,500$2042026-06-2619811,456
Plantation Woods3591 Wood Hill Dr$130,000$1302026-06-2619801,002
Killearn Acres3300 Gallant Fox Trl$315,000$2012026-06-2519781,569
Betton Hills2424 Winthrop Rd$525,000$1952026-06-2019762,698
Betton Hills1561 Spruce Ave$265,000$2182026-06-1519501,217
Killearn Acres6047 Pimlico Ct$625,000$2182026-06-1519942,864
Forest Heights1908 Skyland Dr$335,000$1602026-06-1519682,100
Timber Lake1562 Sprucewood Trl$215,000$2142026-06-1219881,007
Killearn Acres5135 Pimlico Dr$760,000$2312026-06-0920003,288
Killearn Acres3229 Majestic Prince Trl$294,000$2042026-06-0819821,440
Savannah Crossing2738 W Tharpe St Apt 404$140,000$1162026-06-0820041,209
Meadowbrook714 Riggins Rd$385,000$2012026-06-0519891,912
Killearn Acres6845 Hill Gail Trl$284,500$2312026-06-0519831,233
Autumn Woods5751 Cypress Cir$245,000$2222026-06-0519791,104
Betton Hills2005 Lee Ave$440,000$1802026-06-0419562,445
Camelot Park439 Grail Dr$275,000$2132026-06-0319901,293
Killearn Acres6455 Joe Cotton Trl$320,000$2182026-06-0319831,468
Forest Heights2007 Rosedale Dr$308,000$1872026-06-0319541,644
Betton Hills1568 Spruce Ave$399,000$3572026-06-0119471,117
Betton Hills1541 Hickory Ave$475,000$2972026-05-2919931,600
Plantation Woods4222 Fred George Rd$275,000$2152026-05-2919901,278
Meadowbrook751 Violet St$370,000$1822026-05-1819912,028
Betton Hills2406 Troland Rd$600,000$2412026-05-1519692,489
Savannah Crossing2738 W Tharpe St Apt 405$137,000$1132026-05-1520041,209
Betton Hills1503 Spruce Ave$485,000$2302026-05-1419482,112
Timber Lake1451 Grey Fox Run$265,000$2122026-05-1319871,248
Camelot Park2400 Castletower Rd$309,000$2042026-05-1219741,512
Killearn Acres5024 Pimlico Dr$315,000$2102026-05-1119831,500
Betton Hills1308 Betton Rd$397,500$1872026-05-0819532,122
Savannah Crossing2738 W Tharpe St Apt 2106$138,000$1142026-05-0820041,209
Killearn Acres6708 Johnstown Loop$380,000$2102026-05-0719841,808
Autumn Woods5620 Cypress Cir$185,000$2182026-05-051977850
Forest Heights1609 Sunset Ln$289,000$1812026-05-0519691,596
Camelot Park2934 Modred Ln$273,000$2132026-05-0419921,283
Forest Heights1506 W Tharpe St$213,000$1662026-05-0419531,287
Lafayette Oaks2303 Napoleon Bonaparte Dr$395,000$1672026-05-0119852,365
Camelot Park1082 Richardson Rd$235,000$1222026-04-2819781,922
Autumn Woods4593 Autumn Woods Way$170,000$1392026-04-2419761,222
Killearn Acres6525 Iron Liege Trl$310,000$2212026-04-2219831,403
Betton Hills2240 Armistead Rd$660,000$1682026-04-2119693,932
Betton Hills2103 Ellicott Dr$540,000$2302026-04-2019742,352
Forest Heights1920 Sunset Ln$280,000$2162026-04-2019601,296
Betton Hills1221 Betton Rd$380,000$1672026-04-1719502,280
Killearn Acres6620 Reigh Count Trl$310,000$2322026-04-1719881,336
Forest Heights1907 Sharon Rd$275,000$1752026-04-1719581,575
Killearn Acres3413 Native Dancer Trl$325,000$2142026-04-1519781,516
Autumn Woods5680 Doonesbury Way$175,400$1622026-04-1419771,080
Lafayette Oaks5325 Touraine Dr$525,000$1882026-04-1319782,790
Killearn Acres6842 Hill Gail Trl$360,000$2842026-04-1319881,266
Killearn Acres6615 Kingman Trl$495,000$2212026-04-1020062,240
Savannah Crossing2738 W Tharpe St Apt 304$145,000$1202026-04-1020041,209
Plantation Woods3368 Wood Hill Dr$280,000$1592026-04-0819791,764
Autumn Woods4501 Hickory Forest Cir$175,000$1922026-04-061977910
Killearn Acres3228 Lord Murphy Trl$289,000$1572026-04-0319891,836
Autumn Woods4504 Autumn Woods Way$229,900$2002026-04-0319761,150
Killearn Acres2956 Whirlaway Trl$352,000$2082026-03-3119801,693
Forest Heights1917 Sharon Rd$290,000$1762026-03-2619601,651

This concludes our report on high appreciating Tallahassee neighborhoods, please give us a call at (850) 366-8917 or drop us a note if you have questions or comments about the information contained within. 

Did you know that hiring the most market-aware real estate agent can save you money when you sell or buy a home? Take a look at what our past customers have to say, you can read thousands of real customer reviews reported on Google, Facebook and Zillow right here: http://www.manausa.com/testimonials.

Related Posts