Astoria Park Homes For Sale & Neighborhood Guide

Astoria Park is an established Northwest Tallahassee neighborhood in ZIP code 32303, north of Hartsfield Road and west of Old Bainbridge Road. The community contains about 150 detached single-family homes, with much of the housing stock dating from the mid-1960s through the late 1970s. Similar-sized homes can sell at materially different prices here, making condition, renovations, major-system updates, and property-specific comparable sales especially important.

Astoria Park Key Facts

  • Location: Northwest Tallahassee, Florida 32303, north of Hartsfield Road and west of Old Bainbridge Road
  • Housing: Detached single-family homes, with three- and four-bedroom floor plans common
  • Neighborhood Size: About 150 homes
  • Construction Era: Primarily mid-1960s through late 1970s
  • Homeowners Association (HOA): None.
  • Community Development District (CDD): None.
  • Water: City of Tallahassee
  • Electric: City of Tallahassee
  • Sewer: Public sewer
  • Elementary School: Astoria Park Elementary School
  • Middle School: Griffin Middle School
  • High School: Godby High School
  • School assignment verification: Confirm the exact property address through the Leon County Schools address lookup.
  • Homes For Sale: View current Astoria Park homes for sale

Astoria Park Summary

Astoria Park offers buyers an established Northwest Tallahassee setting with mature residential character and practical access to Hartsfield Road, Old Bainbridge Road, North Monroe Street, downtown Tallahassee, area colleges, shopping, restaurants, and other parts of Leon County. The neighborhood’s housing stock reflects decades of individual maintenance, remodeling, and system replacement rather than the uniform condition found in a recently built subdivision.

That variation is central to understanding value. Two Astoria Park homes with similar living area can differ materially in roofing, HVAC equipment, electrical and plumbing systems, windows, kitchens, bathrooms, flooring, additions, drainage, landscaping, and overall renovation quality. Buyers comparing properties should focus on the closest physical and condition matches rather than assuming that similar square footage creates similar value.

For broader comparisons, explore 32303 homes for sale, browse other Tallahassee communities and neighborhood guides, and review Manausa’s Astoria Park real estate report. The live property search immediately below shows current Astoria Park listings.

Homes For Sale in Astoria Park

9 Properties
1818 Doric Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#397804
2526 Old Bainbridge Road
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#402112
2414 WILLAMETTE Road
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#402846
1826 Wales Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#403174
2501 Colleen Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds4Baths2MLS#403404
2510 Old Bainbridge
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#404355
2506 Colleen Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds4Baths2MLS#404994
2517 Colleen Drive
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
Beds3Baths2MLS#405346
2430 & 2432 Atlas Road 2
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
MLS#405889

About Astoria Park

Astoria Park is a long-established Northwest Tallahassee neighborhood containing about 150 detached single-family homes. Three- and four-bedroom floor plans are common, and much of the original housing stock was built from the mid-1960s through the late 1970s.

Decades of ownership have created meaningful property-to-property differences. Buyers can encounter homes with largely original finishes, partially renovated interiors, updated kitchens and bathrooms, newer roofs and HVAC systems, replaced windows, additions, or combinations of older and newer components. Effective condition can therefore matter as much as original construction year.

Recent sales also show why square footage alone is not enough to establish value in Astoria Park. Homes with relatively similar living area can close at very different prices when condition, renovation level, transaction circumstances, and major-system quality differ.

Location And Northwest Tallahassee Access

Astoria Park is in Tallahassee’s 32303 ZIP code, north of Hartsfield Road and west of Old Bainbridge Road. The location provides practical access to North Monroe Street, downtown Tallahassee, Florida State University, Tallahassee State College, shopping, restaurants, medical services, and other Northwest Tallahassee destinations.

Buyers comparing current inventory can monitor newly listed Tallahassee homes and Tallahassee open houses. The City of Tallahassee also maintains a parks and recreation directory for buyers evaluating access to public recreational facilities.

Homes, Lots, And Physical Character

Astoria Park primarily contains detached single-family homes from the 1960s and 1970s. The neighborhood’s mature age means exterior appearance, interior finish level, floor-plan functionality, storage, additions, driveways, landscaping, fencing, and usable yard area can vary from property to property.

Because the housing stock has been standing for several decades, buyers should evaluate more than cosmetic updates. Roofing, HVAC equipment, electrical systems, plumbing, windows, water heaters, drainage, sewer connections, additions, permits, insulation, and prior repairs can materially affect future ownership costs and a home’s effective condition.

Sellers can strengthen a buyer’s understanding of an established home by organizing documentation for major improvements, replacements, permitted work, warranties, and repair history. Buyers should combine those records with inspections and other normal due diligence rather than assuming that a remodeled appearance means every major component has been updated.

Get Our Free Market Update

Weekly Special real estate report covers the Tallahassee real estate market

Other buyers, sellers, lenders, and real estate agents have this critical information, and now you can too!

Get immediate access to our most recent newsletter.

Let more than 30 years of experience work for you with charts, graphs, and analysis of the Tallahassee housing market.

Each Monday morning we send out a simple, one-page report that provides a snapshot of the Tallahassee housing market. It only takes 2 minutes to read, but it gives you better market intelligence than most real estate agents possess. Just tell us where to send it below!

HOA, CDD, Utilities, And Ownership Considerations

Astoria Park has no homeowners association and no Community Development District, so owners do not have neighborhood-level HOA or CDD assessments. Property-specific ownership costs still include property taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, repairs, and improvements chosen by the owner.

City of Tallahassee water and electric service and public sewer serve Astoria Park. Buyers should confirm service details for the exact property through City of Tallahassee Utilities, particularly when evaluating an older home or planning substantial renovations.

Tax assessment and market value are different questions. Manausa’s discussion of the Tax Appraiser explains why a taxable assessment should not be treated as a substitute for current comparable-market evidence when evaluating what a property is likely to sell for.

For parcel, ownership, and tax research, use the Leon County Property Appraiser, Leon County Tax Collector, and Tallahassee-Leon County GIS. Buyers evaluating flood exposure should use the FEMA Flood Map Service Center for the exact parcel and combine that information with inspections, seller disclosures, drainage observations, and insurance research.

Schools Serving Astoria Park

Astoria Park is currently associated with Astoria Park Elementary School, Griffin Middle School, and Godby High School.

School attendance boundaries can change, so buyers should verify the exact property address through the official Leon County Schools address lookup before relying on an assignment.

Astoria Park Market Snapshot

Astoria Park’s short-term sales data require careful interpretation. Recent transactions include homes with relatively similar living areas but a much wider spread in sale prices and price per square foot. That pattern makes the latest neighborhood average sensitive to the mix and circumstances of the properties that happened to sell.

The permanent modules below should therefore be read together. The newest readings matter most for current direction, while the longer history provides perspective on how prices, values, home sizes, and transaction volume have moved across multiple housing cycles. The strongest property-specific conclusion still comes from the most comparable recent sales and current competing inventory.

Astoria Park Home Prices

The price graph tracks average completed sale prices by year. Recent averages can move sharply when a small group of unusually low-priced, highly renovated, distressed, or otherwise atypical transactions enters the annual sales mix.

Average Home Price

The latest average should not be interpreted as the percentage change in every Astoria Park home’s value. Buyers and sellers should examine which properties produced the average and give the greatest weight to homes with similar condition, living area, renovation level, location, and transaction characteristics.

Astoria Park Home Values

The value graph tracks average sale price per square foot. This helps normalize some differences in home size, but the wide spread among recent transactions shows why price per square foot cannot fully account for condition, renovations, floor-plan utility, major systems, additions, lot characteristics, or transaction circumstances.

Average Home Value

Price per square foot works best as one indicator within a broader comparable-sale analysis. A dated property and a thoroughly renovated property can have similar square footage while competing at materially different price levels.

Astoria Park Home Sizes

The size graph tracks the average finished living area of Astoria Park homes sold in each year. Reading it beside the price and value graphs helps identify periods when the mix of larger or smaller homes influenced neighborhood averages.

Average Home Size

Recent sales demonstrate that relatively similar living areas do not guarantee similar sale prices. Layout, bedroom and bathroom configuration, additions, effective condition, major-system updates, renovation quality, and lot utility should be considered along with finished square footage.

Recent Astoria Park Home Sales

The sales table provides transaction-level evidence behind the neighborhood trends. Compare closing date, sale price, price per square foot, construction year, finished area, sale type, condition, renovation history, and property characteristics before deciding which transactions deserve the greatest weight.

Home Sales in Astoria Park

AddressPricePrice / SQFClosing DateYear BuiltSQFSale Type
1829 Wales Dr$180,000$972026-09-1819721,864Resale
1815 Salmon Dr$215,000$1592026-05-2619731,352Resale
2501 Colleen Dr$110,000$762026-03-3019731,447Resale
2618 Mayfair Road$271,000$2122026-03-1219701,281Resale
2505 Mayfair Rd$237,500$1792026-03-0219671,324Resale
1828 Mayfair Rd$206,500$1682026-02-0919771,230Resale
2614 Mayfair Rd$235,000$1952026-01-2819701,204Resale
1825 Wales Dr$39,900$302026-01-2819721,324Resale
1823 Salmon Dr$259,900$2132025-10-1319771,218Resale
2618 Mayfair Road$150,000$1172025-09-2219701,281Resale
1819 Mayfair Rd$266,000$1912025-09-1119751,396Resale
1608 Salmon Dr$290,000$1842025-07-1819711,573Resale
1800 Salmon Dr$239,000$1802025-07-1419711,330Resale
2516 Colleen Dr$269,900$1652025-06-2419721,638Resale
2533 Willamette Rd$185,000$1222025-06-1819711,516Resale
1813 Salmon Dr$260,000$1482025-05-3019731,758Resale
1833 Mayfair Rd$270,000$1732025-05-2819761,562Resale
1605 Salmon Dr$283,800$2132025-04-1719711,334Resale
1826 Mayfair Rd$232,000$1312025-03-2119771,770Resale
1824 Doric Dr$223,400$1792024-12-0419761,249Resale
1836 Doric Dr$200,000$1672024-10-0819761,196Resale
2404 Ionic Ct$218,900$1432024-08-2019771,530Resale
2534 Old Bainbridge Rd$175,000$1642024-08-0919721,068Resale
1836 Portland Ave$227,000$1462024-07-1519741,553Resale
1834 Doric Dr$217,600$1932024-06-2819761,128Resale
1826 Wales Dr$225,000$1622024-06-0519721,388Resale
2414 Gothic Dr$218,400$1832024-06-0319761,196Resale
2610 Mayfair Rd$338,000$1612024-05-2319712,096Resale
1811 Salmon Dr$248,000$1542024-03-2619731,610Resale
1816 Portland Ave$195,900$1742024-03-2219731,125Resale
2401 Tree Top Ct$279,000$2182024-01-1919761,279Resale
2413 Mayfair Rd$240,000$1952023-12-0819711,232Resale
1710 Salmon Dr$221,500$1492023-11-0819691,484Resale
2403 Gothic Dr$200,000$1452023-10-1619761,380Resale
1815 Salmon Dr$234,500$1732023-09-1319731,352Resale
1808 Mayfair Rd$237,000$1462023-08-1119721,627Resale
2406 Gothic Dr$234,900$1542023-08-0819761,530Resale
1822 Portland Ave$245,000$2032023-07-3119731,204Resale
2601 Mayfair Rd$183,000$1492023-07-2819671,232Resale
2529 Colleen Dr$185,000$1332023-07-1919721,392Resale
2502 Old Bainbridge Rd$253,000$1582023-07-1219721,604Resale
2534 Old Bainbridge Rd$165,000$1542023-06-1619721,068Resale
2410 Gothic Dr$210,000$1762023-05-3119761,196Resale
2414 Ionic Ct$205,800$1322023-05-1619771,564Resale
1832 Portland Ave$239,700$1992023-03-1019741,204Resale
1831 Doric Dr$162,000$1292022-12-2019771,251Resale
1817 Mayfair Rd$207,600$1442022-11-2319781,438Resale
2516 Colleen Dr$215,000$1312022-10-2519721,638Resale
2613 Mayfair Rd$235,000$1762022-10-2419721,334Resale
1807 Mayfair Rd$225,000$1612022-09-1919731,396Resale
2510 Old Bainbridge Road$200,000$1792022-08-1719721,119Resale
1812 Portland Ave$253,000$1572022-06-3019731,612Resale
1829 Wales Dr$230,000$1232022-06-1319721,864Resale
1816 Doric Dr$228,000$2052022-05-2319751,113Resale
1833 Mayfair Rd$260,000$1662022-05-1119761,562Resale
1818 Doric Dr$222,000$1862022-04-2919751,196Resale
1833 Wales Dr$226,000$1502022-04-1819711,502Resale
1833 Mayfair Rd$130,000$832022-02-0919761,562Resale
1835 Doric Dr$174,000$1412021-12-0119761,230Resale
2505 Mayfair Rd$215,000$1622021-11-2419671,324Resale
1827 Mayfair Rd$165,000$1292021-10-2019741,278Resale
1803 Salmon Dr$195,000$1662021-09-2219721,175Resale
2403 Gothic Dr$189,900$1382021-09-0319761,380Resale
1803 Mayfair Rd$180,000$1442021-08-2519731,247Resale
1833 Wales Dr$110,000$732021-08-1319711,502Resale
2418 Mayfair Rd$175,000$1082021-08-1219691,621Resale
1810 Wales Dr$192,000$1222021-08-0919721,568Resale
1823 Salmon Dr$128,000$1052021-08-0619771,218Resale
2610 Mayfair Rd$294,000$1402021-07-0919712,096Resale
1824 Doric Dr$170,000$1362021-07-0619761,249Resale
1820 Doric Dr$220,000$1742021-06-3019751,265Resale
2401 Willamette Rd$210,000$1502021-06-2119671,400Resale
2417 Willamette Rd$210,000$1112021-06-0719721,898Resale
2514 Colleen Dr$205,000$1262021-06-0419731,624Resale
1819 Wales Dr$156,500$1112021-05-2819721,404Resale
1828 Mayfair Rd$155,000$1262021-05-2419771,230Resale
1830 Wales Dr$169,900$972021-02-1519711,757Resale
1616 Salmon Dr$180,000$1192021-02-0219671,515Resale
1605 Salmon Dr$198,400$1492021-01-1219711,334Resale
2416 Gothic Dr$165,000$982020-12-3019761,690Resale
1833 Doric Dr$155,000$1262020-12-2819771,230Resale
1822 Mayfair Rd$164,000$1192020-11-0619771,374Resale
2404 Ionic Ct$160,000$1052020-10-2919771,530Resale
2513 Willamette Rd$169,000$1062020-10-2319721,588Resale
1824 Doric Dr$125,000$1002020-08-1219761,249Resale
2509 Colleen Dr$165,000$1102020-07-2819731,500Resale
1836 Portland Ave$156,100$1012020-06-2519741,553Resale
1806 Mayfair Rd$148,500$942020-04-3019731,580Resale
1605 Salmon Dr$50,000$372020-04-2219711,334Resale
1826 Mayfair Rd$125,000$712020-03-1319771,770Resale
2413 Tree Top Ct$145,000$1172019-12-3119761,238Resale
1831 Mayfair Rd$131,500$832019-12-1319751,590Resale
2630 Mayfair Rd$125,000$962019-11-0819711,305Resale
2605 Mayfair Rd$131,000$822019-09-3019691,596Resale
2634 Mayfair Rd$157,500$1042019-09-2119721,512Resale
2545 Willamette Rd$143,000$932019-09-1219711,534Resale
2409 Willamette Rd$129,000$812019-08-2819711,594Resale
2418 Gothic Dr$143,000$1322019-07-2619711,082Resale
2414 Ionic Ct$144,000$922019-07-1619771,564Resale
2401 Gothic Dr$149,500$1222019-05-3119771,222Resale

Recent Astoria Park transactions reinforce the need for property-specific analysis because homes that appear similar by age and size can produce very different results. The most useful comparable sales are those that most closely match the subject home’s actual condition, improvements, layout, and market position.

For broader current conditions, follow Manausa’s Tallahassee real estate market analysis and review the Astoria Park real estate report. Neighborhood statistics establish context, but current competing listings and the most relevant recent sales should drive property-specific decisions.

The market data establishes the neighborhood framework. The next step is to apply that evidence to the exact home’s condition, renovation history, major systems, lot utility, current competition, financing, insurance, and expected ownership costs before deciding what to offer or where to position an asking price.

Buying here? Talk to a buyer’s agent first.

A Joe Manausa Team member on your side before you fall for a house. Leave your name and email and we will reach out.

Buying A Home In Astoria Park

Astoria Park buyers should compare the complete property rather than focus only on asking price or price per square foot. Homes from the neighborhood’s principal construction era can differ substantially in roofs, HVAC systems, electrical and plumbing components, windows, kitchens, bathrooms, additions, drainage, flooring, landscaping, and overall maintenance.

Buyers planning a purchase can benefit from preparing before the right property appears. Manausa’s guide to preparing to buy a home within the next six months emphasizes building market knowledge, clarifying priorities, and getting the financing and representation process organized before making a decision.

Negotiation should remain tied to the home’s likely market value and the complete contract. Manausa’s explanation of how often a home seller may counter provides useful context for buyers deciding how to respond when price and terms move through several rounds of negotiation.

During due diligence, buyers should review seller disclosures, inspection findings, permits for material improvements, available property records, insurance considerations, flood information, and any issues raised by the home’s age or condition. A survey can also clarify boundaries, easements, and improvements when those matters are relevant to the specific property.

Manausa’s Tallahassee home-buying resources can help organize the process. Buyers can create a Home Finder, compare payments with the mortgage calculator, test budget assumptions with the home affordability calculator, review the first-time home buyer guide, and use the team’s preferred home-service vendors when inspection, repair, or maintenance expertise is needed.

Selling A Home In Astoria Park

Astoria Park sellers should resist using one broad neighborhood average as a substitute for property-specific analysis. Recent transactions include a wide range of outcomes among homes with relatively similar living areas, making condition, renovation level, major systems, floor plan, lot characteristics, and transaction circumstances important when selecting comparable sales.

Negotiating leverage begins before an offer arrives. Manausa’s guide to using leverage to negotiate a better price when selling explains why pricing, preparation, exposure, and buyer competition work together rather than operating as separate decisions.

Online presentation should also target the buyers most likely to act. Manausa’s analysis of how home buyers leave clues on the internet provides useful context for focusing marketing on the people who are actively comparing homes rather than treating all online traffic as equally valuable.

Organize permits, invoices, warranties, roof and HVAC information, surveys, repair records, and renovation documentation before launch. Photography and listing copy should accurately communicate the home’s layout, updates, systems, yard characteristics, storage, and effective condition so buyers can understand why it differs from nearby alternatives.

Owners preparing to sell can request a property-specific home evaluation, review Manausa’s Tallahassee home-selling resources, see how the team sells homes, examine the real estate marketing plan, and review seller testimonials. Current competition should be considered alongside closed sales before choosing the final asking price.

Where is the Tallahassee market headed?

New articles as they publish, plus the Monday market report. Free, by email.

Nearby Neighborhoods

For additional comparisons, browse the complete directory of Tallahassee communities and current homes for sale in ZIP code 32303.

Astoria Park Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Astoria Park in Tallahassee?

Astoria Park is in Northwest Tallahassee’s 32303 ZIP code, north of Hartsfield Road and west of Old Bainbridge Road.

What types of homes are in Astoria Park?

Astoria Park primarily contains detached single-family homes. Much of the housing stock dates from the mid-1960s through the late 1970s, and three- and four-bedroom floor plans are common.

Does Astoria Park have an HOA?

No. Astoria Park has no homeowners association.

Does Astoria Park have a CDD?

No. Astoria Park has no Community Development District.

Which utilities serve Astoria Park?

Astoria Park homes use City of Tallahassee water and electric service along with public sewer.

Which public schools serve Astoria Park?

Astoria Park is currently associated with Astoria Park Elementary School, Griffin Middle School, and Godby High School. Buyers should verify the exact property address through Leon County Schools because attendance boundaries can change.

What should buyers inspect in an older Astoria Park home?

Buyers should evaluate the roof, HVAC equipment, plumbing, electrical systems, windows, drainage, sewer connections, additions, permits, previous renovations, and other property-specific components during normal due diligence.

Why can Astoria Park sale prices vary so much?

Recent sales show that homes with relatively similar living areas can close at very different prices. Condition, renovation level, major-system updates, property characteristics, and transaction circumstances should be considered before treating a sale as a strong comparable.

We Are Here To Help

Astoria Park buyers benefit from combining neighborhood market data with a property-specific review of condition, renovations, major systems, lot utility, financing, insurance, and comparable sales. Sellers benefit from pricing and marketing that clearly distinguish their home’s condition and improvements from competing established properties.

Contact the Joe Manausa Team at Xcellence Realty for help buying or selling a home in Astoria Park.

Thousands of Joe Manausa Team customers have left reviews on Google, Facebook, and Zillow. Read the Tallahassee real estate agent reviews.

Ready to talk to a local expert?

Moving to, within, or from Tallahassee, a Joe Manausa Team member gives you the local answers a smooth transaction needs.