There are many homes in Tallahassee that fall outside of formal subdivisions, and as part of our neighborhood reports, we throw all of these into one “pot.”
This diverse collection of homes for sale that are not in subdivisions is shown below, and recent similar properties that sold have been corralled and measured for average price, average value, and average size and these trends are reported below.
Tallahassee Homes for Sale NOT in a Subdivision
Not In Subdivision Homes for Sale
For this article, we have created 3 graphs that identify average home prices, average home values, and average home sizes for homes outside of subdivisions, and we have also included a table of the most recent 1,000 closed home sales as well.
For all of the graphs in this report, you will find the number of closed home sales for each year (red columns, measured on the left vertical axis), and an important real estate statistic shown in blue (measured on the right vertical axis).
It is important to note that the narrative contained below is for sales through December for all previous years but through the middle of November in 2019. The graphs and the closed sales table will be continuously updated into the future (meaning bookmark this page if you always want to know the current status of homes outside of Tallahassee Subdivisions).
Average Home Prices
The average price of a home sold outside of Tallahassee subdivisions is $253K, up more than 2% from last year’s average and now heading towards a new record high that will likely be achieved within the next 18 months.
Average Home Prices
Because we have lumped all homes not in subdivisions into one big group, we expect fluctuations in the averages of everything we measure. Styles, land size, age and going to have a much larger range in this group than will those found in formal subdivisions.
Home sales activity is consistent with the records for the past thirty years. When 2019 comes to an end, it will likely find that the number of homes sold outside of subdivisions will fall right into the middle of the thirty-year average. This means the market is good and has plenty of upside potential. Home sellers using an omnichannel marketing plan should expect multiple buyers and an offer(s) right away for homes priced below $500K.
Average Home Values
The average value of a home sold outside of a formal subdivision is flat for the year, but have risen nearly 3% since our last report.
Average Home Values
Just as we forecast a few months ago, values would rise and offset the few large, low-value sales that were reported earlier in the year. Expect to see values continue to rise and follow the market from here on out.
Video Answers To Your Questions












Video Housing Market Reports











Your Local Expert In Tallahassee
When moving to, in, or from Tallahassee, you will fare better if you work with a local expert. We are here to help. If you have further questions on the Tallahassee real estate market, you can leave a comment below, give us a call at (850) 366-8917, or drop us a note and we'll give you the local information needed to ensure a successful, smooth transaction.
As a local born and raised in Tallahassee with a focus on customer service, I promise you'll find great success when working with Joe Manausa Real Estate, just as have our past customers. You can read thousands of their reviews reported on Google, Facebook and Zillow right here: Real Estate Agent Reviews Tallahassee.
Have you heard about my new book "The Business of Getting Business?" It's a comprehensive guide for small businesses to help them make the move to digital. For those of us who want to survive and thrive in a world where large corporations are taking over, it is a must-read. It's also the perfect guide for how to sell a home in the digital age. You can find The Business Of Getting Business by clicking on any of the trusted retailers below.
![]() |
![]() |
|||
![]() |
![]() |
|||
Think all REALTORS are alike?
Read what people are saying about working with Joe Manausa Real Estate! You can see thousands of real customer reviews reported on Google, Facebook and Zillow at this link: CLICK HERE FOR REAL ESTATE AGENT REVIEWS.
Average Home Sizes
The average Tallahassee home size sold outside of formal subdivisions typically falls in a range of 1,800 to 2,200 square feet, and this year has been no different.
Average Home Sizes
The 269 homes sold outside of subdivisions in Tallahassee this year have averaged 2,092 square feet.
Tallahassee Homes Sold Outside Of Formal Subdivisions
The following list shows the most recent 1,000 home sales in Leon County located outside of formal subdivisions.
All homes sold outside of formal Leon County SubdivisionsAddress Price Price / SQF Closing Date Year Built SQF Sale Type 241 Old Dirt Rd $399,000 $168 2026-10-01 1971 2,368 Resale 1334 Kings Dr $164,000 $186 2026-10-01 1983 882 Resale 3214 Springdale Dr $315,000 $184 2026-09-30 2000 1,712 Resale 18184 Blountstown Hwy $200,000 $151 2026-09-29 1928 1,324 Resale 1119204160000 $360,000 $130 2026-09-25 1994 2,776 Resale 3164 Lakeshore Dr $520,000 $288 2026-09-25 1956 1,804 Resale 1109200140000 $350,000 $184 2026-09-22 1930 1,902 Resale 727 Miccosukee Road $375,000 $69 2026-09-22 1908 5,401 Resale 628 W Georgia St $360,000 $243 2026-09-21 1932 1,483 Resale 1579 Pine St $160,000 $215 2026-09-18 1950 744 Resale 1312 Alabama St $55,000 $72 2026-09-18 1956 768 Resale 1120204160000 $142,500 $162 2026-09-17 1979 880 Resale 1520 Summerbrooke Dr $530,700 $283 2026-09-16 2026 1,873 New 3113 Parkridge Dr $270,000 $108 2026-09-16 1956 2,508 Resale 5014 Nelly Ln $551,000 $210 2026-09-15 2007 2,630 Resale 2611 Red Arrow Rd $61,000 $57 2026-09-11 1963 1,070 Resale 2100 S Gadsden St $176,500 $196 2026-09-11 1954 900 Resale 3830 Edgewater Dr $497,500 $181 2026-09-10 1996 2,752 Resale 1536 Summerbrooke Dr $598,100 $233 2026-09-08 2025 2,572 New 1700 S Meridian St $340,000 $113 2026-09-04 1948 3,012 Resale 9737 Faraway Farm Road $685,000 $243 2026-09-03 2008 2,818 Resale 1308202190000 $500,000 $223 2026-09-03 2005 2,240 Resale 3429 Lakeshore Dr $322,000 $153 2026-09-03 1972 2,104 Resale 6981 Duck Cove Rd $1,200,000 $392 2026-08-31 1984 3,062 Resale 6552 Kingman Trail $350,000 $186 2026-08-31 1990 1,879 Resale 7083 Grenville Rd $2,925,000 $495 2026-08-31 2022 5,914 Resale 6011 Tindell Ln $384,500 $171 2026-08-31 2006 2,252 Resale 5274 Family Tree Dr $210,000 $153 2026-08-28 1995 1,374 Resale 2366 Natural Bridge Rd $300,000 $195 2026-08-27 1973 1,540 Resale 8548 Scott Tower Rd $580,000 $269 2026-08-24 2026 2,160 New 3732 Ravine Dr $450,000 $222 2026-08-21 1974 2,026 Resale 1568 Summerbrooke Dr $590,900 $230 2026-08-20 2026 2,572 New 2905 Natural Bridge Rd $45,000 $49 2026-08-20 1972 910 Resale 9025 Buck Lake Rd $375,000 $141 2026-08-19 1986 2,661 Resale 2334206070000 $100,000 $85 2026-08-18 1954 1,180 Resale 2049 Solomon Ct $735,000 $283 2026-08-14 2023 2,595 Resale 10080 Mahan Dr $899,000 $456 2026-08-14 2022 1,972 Resale 1225204070000 $225,000 $199 2026-08-14 1976 1,128 Resale 1525 Paul Russell Rd $165,000 $149 2026-08-14 1947 1,104 Resale 4115200040000 $35,000 $41 2026-08-14 1965 864 Resale 4611 Granada Blvd $115,000 $93 2026-08-14 1958 1,235 Resale 2801 Hadley Rd $590,000 $271 2026-08-13 2017 2,178 Resale 409 Midflow St $229,900 $129 2026-08-12 1954 1,780 Resale 1552 Summerbrooke Dr $834,800 $242 2026-08-11 2026 3,447 New 111 S Gadsden St Apt 1 $545,000 $181 2026-08-11 1982 3,016 Resale 1414 Idlewild Dr $190,000 $122 2026-08-11 1955 1,563 Resale 2709 Wharton Circle $700,000 $261 2026-08-07 1999 2,681 Resale 604 W 6TH Ave $220,000 $183 2026-08-07 2005 1,200 Resale 2217 Thomasville Rd $1,865,000 $434 2026-08-06 2016 4,301 Resale 2124204030000 $330,000 $148 2026-08-05 1946 2,231 Resale 4101202590000 $200,000 $138 2026-08-03 2006 1,449 Resale 730 E 6TH Ave Apt 1 $645,000 $228 2026-07-31 1935 2,835 Resale 7877 Jared Way $2,250,000 $471 2026-07-31 2024 4,777 Resale 16069 Bob Ellis Rd $190,000 $165 2026-07-31 1973 1,152 Resale 4831 Jackson Cove Rd $225,000 $172 2026-07-30 2007 1,308 Resale 8014 Susan Bradford Ln $2,875,000 $482 2026-07-27 2022 5,969 Resale 2709 Baum Rd $200,000 $270 2026-07-24 1946 740 Resale 16998 Blountstown Hwy $225,000 $183 2026-07-24 1968 1,232 Resale 4483 Corbin Court $338,000 $200 2026-07-17 1995 1,686 Resale 4114206070000 $190,000 $146 2026-07-17 1977 1,300 Resale 4871 Old Bainbridge Rd $170,000 $183 2026-07-13 1976 928 Resale 1111200080000 $700,000 $200 2026-07-10 1989 3,496 Resale 1038 Qodesh Ln $181,500 $159 2026-07-10 1964 1,140 Resale 4785 Chaires Cross Rd $535,000 $162 2026-07-08 1999 3,299 Resale 1408 Pullen Rd $610,000 $158 2026-07-08 1930 3,870 Resale 4414204260000 $36,200 2026-07-06 Resale 11330 Whitehouse Rd $216,000 $176 2026-07-01 1978 1,224 Resale 12451 Back Trail Rd $206,000 $179 2026-07-01 1984 1,152 Resale 8626 Proctor Rd $1,085,000 $354 2026-06-29 2024 3,063 Resale 1603 N M L King Jr Blvd $245,000 $182 2026-06-29 1950 1,344 Resale 837 Park Ave E $245,000 $329 2026-06-26 1930 744 Resale 1007 Williams Landing Rd $1,169,000 $408 2026-06-25 2024 2,864 New 2819 Pound Dr $275,000 $191 2026-06-22 1976 1,437 Resale 8121 Proctor Rd $2,049,000 $538 2026-06-18 2023 3,807 Resale 4520 Garden Oaks Way $424,900 $190 2026-06-18 2025 2,239 New 275 E Harrison St $302,000 $201 2026-06-18 2000 1,504 Resale 2430 Talco Hills Dr $153,000 $151 2026-06-12 1992 1,015 Resale 1461 Pine St $431,500 $214 2026-06-09 1994 2,016 Resale 3104206510000 $86,000 $56 2026-06-05 1946 1,530 Resale 1511 Pine St $360,000 $258 2026-06-02 1992 1,394 Resale 2223202500000 $354,500 $167 2026-06-02 1967 2,120 Resale 8754 Scott Tower Rd $165,000 $165 2026-05-29 1978 1,000 Resale 3418 Lakeshore Dr $1,368,200 $223 2026-05-29 1952 6,133 Resale 2890 Green Forest Ln $390,000 $184 2026-05-29 1993 2,118 Resale 5301 Gentle Breeze Dr $469,000 $284 2026-05-26 1985 1,650 Resale 18842 Star Hill Ln $338,000 $318 2026-05-26 1961 1,064 Resale 1529 Live Oak Dr Apt A $209,700 $175 2026-05-22 1948 1,201 Resale 1791 Old Briar Trl $275,000 $154 2026-05-22 1976 1,784 Resale 3415 Woodley Rd $720,000 $176 2026-05-21 1972 4,082 Resale 213107C0070 $21,000 2026-05-21 Resale 810 Middlebrooks Circle $614,000 $246 2026-05-19 1964 2,491 Resale 3107202820000 $50,000 $52 2026-05-19 1953 960 Resale 1235 Live Oak Plantation Rd $2,150,000 $532 2026-05-15 1985 4,040 Resale 125 Belmont Rd $199,000 $158 2026-05-15 1998 1,260 Resale 322 Spruce Creek Dr $670,000 $293 2026-05-15 1994 2,283 Resale 509 N Copeland St $272,500 $204 2026-05-11 2008 1,337 Resale 2811 Pound Dr $240,000 $118 2026-05-08 1975 2,040 Resale 3100 Old St Augustine Rd $350,000 $219 2026-05-08 1958 1,601 Resale 1614 S Meridian St $450,000 $130 2026-05-07 1940 3,473 Resale 3842 Edgewater Dr $412,500 $302 2026-05-07 1964 1,368 Resale
Did our November 2019 report on homes located outside of formal subdivisions provide you the information you were seeking? If not, you can give us a call at (850) 366-8917 or drop us a note and we’ll help you with your specific Tallahassee real estate needs.
As a local born and raised in Tallahassee with a focus on customer service, I promise you’ll find great success when working with Joe Manausa Team at Xcellence Realty, just as have our past customers. You can thousands of their reviews reported on Google, Facebook and Zillow right here: Real Estate Agent Reviews Tallahassee.
Have you heard about my new book “The Business of Getting Business?” It’s a comprehensive guide for small businesses to help them make the move to digital. For those of us who want to survive and thrive in a world where large corporations are taking over, it is a must-read.
You can find it on Amazon (It will be published in Feb 2020, reserve your copy today at a pre-published rate).






