Heartwood Hills is a residential neighborhood located in NE Tallahassee, featuring larger homes on lots of 1.5 to 4.4 acres of land.
This area is known for its assortment of beautiful home styles, varying sizes, and relatively affordable prices. Homes in Heartwood Hills typically range from 1,500 to 3,600 square feet in size yet typically sell for less than $500K.
Heartwood Hills Schools
Heartwood Hills is zoned for the following Leon County public schools:
This Heartwood Hills neighborhood report includes charts and graphs that display average home prices, home values, and home sizes, as well as a list of the most recent closed home sales in Heartwood Hills.
For each of the three real estate graphs found in this Tallahassee housing report, you will find the number of closed home sales for each year (red columns, measured on the left vertical axis) and an important real estate statistic shown in blue (measured on the right vertical axis).
It is important to note that the narrative below is for sales through December for all previous years but through four weeks of January for 2024. The graphs and the closed sales table will be continuously updated in the future (meaning, bookmark this page if you always want to know the current status of homes in Heartwood Hills).
Heartwood Hills Home Prices
In 2023, the average price of homes sold in Heartwood Hills decreased by over 17%. This decline primarily resulted from the sale of smaller-than-average homes, as detailed in the “size” section below.
Average Home Price
Heartwood Hills’ market activity has slowed, aligning with trends observed over the past 15 years. This slowdown doesn’t reflect a diminishing market; instead, it stems from homeowners’ reluctance to move. Currently, only one home is available for sale in Heartwood Hills.
Home Values in Heartwood Hills
The average home value in Heartwood Hills experienced a notable increase in 2023, rising by over 54%. This increase highlights the potential for significant fluctuations in average values within low-liquidity neighborhoods.
Average Home Value
The average value of homes in Heartwood Hills reached $228 per square foot in 2023.
Get Our Free Market Update
Other buyers, sellers, lenders, and real estate agents have this critical information, and now you can too!
Get immediate access to our most recent newsletter.
Let more than 30 years of experience work for you with charts, graphs, and analysis of the Tallahassee housing market.
Each Monday morning we send out a simple, one-page report that provides a snapshot of the Tallahassee housing market. It only takes 2 minutes to read, but it gives you better market intelligence than most real estate agents possess. Just tell us where to send it below!
Heartwood Hills Home Sizes
Homes sold in Heartwood Hills usually range from 2,000 to 2,500 square feet in size. However, the average size of the two homes sold in 2023 was notably smaller, at 1,713 square feet.
Average Home Size
Heartwood Hills Home Sales
Home sales in Heartwood Hills started in 2007, and the list below details these transactions since then. To organize the data, click on the desired column heading to sort the list.
Recent Home Sales In Heartwood HillsAddress Price Price / SQF Closing Date Year Built SQF Sale Type 1525 Lochinvar Ln $90,000 $42 1992-03-26 1992 2,123 New 1504 Lochinvar Ln $70,200 $35 1992-07-21 1992 1,993 New 10533 Valentine Rd S $75,000 $42 1992-11-09 1993 1,770 New 10525 Valentine Road $106,000 $37 1992-12-02 1992 2,851 New 1605 Shakespear Dr $69,500 $28 1993-06-21 1993 2,454 New 10509 Faye Way $135,500 $39 1993-07-20 1993 3,440 New 10633 Valentine Rd N $142,500 $78 1993-08-11 1,838 Resale 10552 Valentine Rd $116,000 $38 1993-08-30 1993 3,091 New 10477 Valentine Rd $100,000 $40 1993-10-04 1993 2,480 New 10529 Valentine Rd S $135,000 $72 1994-02-21 1,884 Resale 10461 Valentine Road $86,700 $35 1994-05-03 1994 2,499 New 10562 Valentine Road South $70,000 $32 1994-05-31 1994 2,175 New 10980 Heartwood Hills Blvd $136,000 $65 1994-05-31 1989 2,085 Resale 10601 Valentine Rd N $155,000 $53 1994-06-28 2,916 Resale 1612 Baum Road $73,000 $34 1994-08-23 1994 2,163 New 10481 Valentine Rd S $90,000 $32 1994-10-11 1995 2,796 New 1630 Shakespear Dr $175,000 $50 1994-10-11 1994 3,483 New 1516 Lochinvar Ln $96,000 $72 1994-11-08 1989 1,330 Resale 10465 Valentine Rd S $152,750 $43 1994-11-29 1994 3,528 New 10508 Casanova Dr $100,000 $38 1994-12-13 1994 2,620 New 10515 Casanova Dr $147,000 $40 1995-02-27 1994 3,660 New 1504 Lochinvar Ln $128,000 $64 1995-08-30 1,993 Resale 10552 Valentine Rd S $119,900 $67 1995-10-27 1993 1,800 Resale 10613 Valentine Rd N $117,000 $76 1995-12-15 1995 1,534 New 10505 Valentine Rd S $121,000 $51 1996-02-22 1996 2,384 New 10493 Valentine Rd S $120,000 $33 1996-06-10 1996 3,624 New 1609 Shakespeare Dr $127,900 $50 1996-06-14 2,574 Resale 10571 Valentine Rd N $85,000 $34 1996-08-19 1996 2,504 New 10515 Faye Way $192,300 $76 1996-09-25 1991 2,518 Resale 1517 Lochinvar Ln $138,000 $46 1996-10-09 1996 3,020 New 10569 Valentine Road North $95,000 $46 1996-10-14 1996 2,080 New 1513 Lochinvar Ln $128,900 $72 1996-10-14 1996 1,779 New 10531 Casanova Dr $118,000 $32 1996-10-17 1996 3,633 New 10470 Valentine Rd S $157,500 $87 1996-10-29 1996 1,803 New 10511 Casanova Dr $164,000 $77 1996-10-30 2,140 Resale 1625 Shakespeare Dr $168,000 $75 1996-12-12 1996 2,248 New 10562 Valentine Rd S $129,000 $72 1997-01-29 1994 1,802 Resale 10610 Valentine Rd N $125,000 $48 1997-02-06 1997 2,608 New 1618 Shakespeare Dr $135,200 $71 1997-02-28 1997 1,906 New 10503 Casanova Dr $95,000 $38 1997-04-24 1997 2,482 New 10506 Faye Way $135,000 $60 1997-06-16 2,261 Resale 10601 Valentine Rd N $193,000 $66 1997-09-25 2,916 Resale 10497 Valentine Rd $150,000 $50 1997-11-06 1997 3,000 New 10613 Valentine Rd N $81,000 $53 1997-11-26 1,534 Resale 1600 Shakespeare Dr $117,670 $41 1997-12-10 1997 2,852 New 10457 Valentine Rd S $159,200 $70 1997-12-31 1996 2,287 New 1605 Shakespeare Dr $136,000 $72 1998-01-30 1993 1,879 Resale 10457 Valentine Rd S $178,000 $78 1998-03-10 1996 2,287 Resale 10478 Valentine Rd S $150,000 $50 1998-06-03 1998 2,993 New 10533 Valentine Rd S $128,500 $81 1998-07-14 1993 1,580 Resale 10600 Valentine Rd N $135,000 $83 1998-12-18 1994 1,630 Resale 10499 Casanova Dr $180,500 $66 1999-02-26 1995 2,732 Resale 10573 Valentine Rd N $146,000 $74 1999-04-14 1997 1,977 New 10980 Heartwood Hills Blvd $157,500 $76 1999-04-28 1989 2,085 Resale 10509 Valentine Rd S $140,700 $82 1999-04-30 1995 1,723 Resale 10517 Valentine Rd S $178,000 $75 1999-05-21 1991 2,368 Resale 10513 Valentine Rd S $107,000 $44 1999-05-27 1999 2,431 New 10617 Valentine Rd N $130,000 $83 1999-06-24 1996 1,566 Resale 1626 Shakespeare Dr $100,000 $33 1999-07-07 1999 3,022 New 1625 Shakespeare Dr $157,000 $70 1999-07-16 1996 2,248 Resale 10477 Valentine Rd S $132,000 $73 1999-07-20 1994 1,806 Resale $145,000 $86 1999-08-12 1994 1,692 Resale 10500 Faye Way $147,000 $85 1999-09-30 1996 1,721 Resale 1610 Shakespear Dr $172,750 $56 1999-12-10 1999 3,082 New 1613 Shakespeare Dr $210,000 $71 2000-03-23 2000 2,968 New 1621 Shakespeare Dr $185,000 $75 2000-04-07 1996 2,458 Resale 10453 Valentine Rd $150,600 $46 2000-04-24 2000 3,256 New 10537 Valentine Rd S $148,000 $51 2000-04-24 2000 2,905 New 10520 Casanova Dr $173,500 $76 2000-04-28 1994 2,283 Resale 10485 Valentine Rd S $120,000 $50 2000-06-23 2000 2,386 New 10543 Casanova Dr $135,000 $36 2000-06-30 2000 3,739 New 10470 Valentine Rd S $164,500 $91 2000-10-02 1996 1,803 Resale 10552 Valentine Rd S $143,500 $80 2000-10-30 1993 1,800 Resale 10520 Casanova Dr $175,000 $77 2000-11-13 1994 2,283 Resale 10980 Heartwood Hills Blvd $172,300 $83 2001-01-05 1989 2,085 Resale 10972 Heartwood Hills Blvd $259,900 $76 2001-01-11 1994 3,415 Resale 1614 Shakespear Dr $140,000 $45 2001-01-30 2000 3,100 New 10535 Casanova Dr $180,000 $82 2001-02-21 1996 2,187 Resale 10473 Valentine Rd S $199,000 $85 2001-03-30 1996 2,333 Resale 10566 Valentine Rd N $182,500 $85 2001-05-14 1990 2,154 Resale 10567 Valentine Rd N $159,000 $86 2001-05-24 1989 1,848 Resale 10513 Valentine Rd S $147,900 $97 2001-05-30 1999 1,523 Resale $185,000 $84 2001-06-15 1997 2,193 Resale 10457 Valentine Rd S $200,000 $87 2001-08-02 1996 2,287 Resale 10545 Valentine Rd S $252,000 $71 2001-08-02 2001 3,525 New 10593 Valentine Rd N $178,000 $86 2001-12-17 1990 2,074 Resale 10629 Valentine Rd $146,000 $86 2001-12-27 1994 1,692 Resale 1618 Shakespeare Dr $177,400 $93 2002-02-28 1997 1,906 Resale 1516 Lochinvar Ln $129,000 $97 2002-03-22 1989 1,330 Resale 1605 Shakespeare Dr $190,000 $101 2002-04-30 1993 1,879 Resale 10645 Valentine Rd N $168,900 $98 2002-05-30 1993 1,727 Resale 10524 Valentine Rd S $153,000 $96 2002-07-08 1994 1,587 Resale 10585 Valentine Rd N $176,700 $87 2002-07-11 1990 2,042 Resale 1621 Shakespeare Dr $210,000 $85 2002-07-11 1996 2,458 Resale 10551 Casanova Dr $138,500 $75 2002-07-24 1997 1,857 Resale 10473 Valentine Rd S $224,900 $96 2002-09-14 1996 2,333 Resale 1604 Baum Rd $230,000 $89 2002-10-14 1992 2,578 Resale $203,000 2002-11-06 2002 New $177,900 2002-12-13 2002 New 10457 Valentine Rd S $249,900 $109 2003-04-10 1996 2,287 Resale 10499 Casanova Dr $219,000 $80 2003-07-02 1995 2,732 Resale 10507 Casanova Dr $217,000 $97 2003-07-09 1995 2,248 Resale 1605 Shakespeare Dr $210,200 $112 2003-07-28 1993 1,879 Resale 10645 Valentine Rd N $185,000 $107 2003-08-29 1993 1,727 Resale 10600 Valentine Rd N $167,500 $103 2003-11-26 1994 1,630 Resale 10474 Valentine Rd S $196,000 2004-01-27 2003 New 10593 Valentine Rd N $205,000 $99 2004-02-25 1990 2,074 Resale 10491 Casanova Dr $196,300 $96 2004-02-27 1994 2,048 Resale 10515 Faye Way $299,000 $119 2004-06-08 1991 2,518 Resale 10481 Valentine Rd S $207,000 $96 2004-06-15 1995 2,156 Resale 10470 Valentine Rd S $229,500 $127 2004-08-01 1996 1,803 Resale 10501 Valentine Rd S $258,000 $160 2004-08-31 1998 1,613 Resale 10466 Valentine Rd S $269,000 $139 2004-09-28 1999 1,930 Resale 1617 Shakespeare Dr $175,000 2004-12-06 2004 New 10485 Valentine Rd S $249,000 $128 2005-02-15 2000 1,940 Resale 10491 Casanova Dr $271,900 $133 2005-02-28 1994 2,048 Resale 10510 Faye Way $215,000 2005-06-21 2005 New 10535 Casanova Dr $225,000 $103 2005-09-14 1996 2,187 Resale 10509 Valentine Rd S $267,900 $155 2006-05-09 1995 1,723 Resale 1618 Shakespeare Dr $297,500 $156 2006-07-27 1997 1,906 Resale 10473 Valentine Rd S $355,000 $152 2006-08-01 1996 2,333 Resale 10518 Faye Way $358,000 $129 2006-08-31 1999 2,766 Resale $300,000 $137 2006-09-27 1989 2,184 Resale 10478 Valentine Rd S $325,000 $148 2007-01-04 1998 2,190 Resale $263,500 $139 2007-02-16 1989 1,896 Resale 1618 Shakespeare Dr $280,000 $147 2007-03-02 1997 1,906 Resale 1602 Shakespeare Dr $285,000 $154 2007-06-15 1998 1,846 Resale 10520 Casanova Dr $345,000 $151 2007-07-20 1994 2,283 Resale 10642 Valentine Rd N $345,000 $150 2007-08-31 1999 2,296 Resale 10478 Valentine Rd S $320,000 $146 2008-03-13 1998 2,190 Resale $375,000 $153 2008-05-01 1990 2,446 Resale $300,000 $169 2008-06-26 1991 1,779 Resale 10519 Casanova Dr $259,000 $115 2008-12-22 1996 2,254 Resale 10525 Valentine Rd S $120,000 $55 2009-03-27 1993 2,180 Resale 10525 Valentine Rd S $253,000 $116 2009-08-17 1993 2,180 Resale 10646 Valentine Rd N $230,000 $138 2009-09-02 1991 1,668 Resale 1626 Shakespeare Dr $280,000 $123 2010-05-27 1999 2,271 Resale 10532 Casanova Dr $235,000 $133 2010-06-11 2002 1,769 Resale 1618 Shakespeare Dr $293,200 $154 2010-07-09 1997 1,906 Resale 10453 Valentine Rd S $287,000 $124 2010-09-07 2000 2,322 Resale 10525 Valentine Rd S $265,000 $123 2011-03-15 1993 2,162 Resale 10562 Valentine Rd S $204,000 $113 2014-02-18 1994 1,802 Resale 10504 Casanova Dr $220,000 $98 2014-03-14 1993 2,235 Resale 10980 Heartwood Hills Blvd $240,000 $115 2014-08-29 1989 2,085 Resale 10972 Heartwood Hills Blvd $196,000 $57 2014-11-20 1994 3,411 Resale 10610 Valentine Rd N $144,100 $78 2015-06-16 1997 1,841 Resale 10972 Heartwood Hills Boulevard $330,000 $97 2015-06-30 1994 3,411 Resale 10535 Casanova Drive $235,000 $107 2015-08-31 1996 2,187 Resale 10610 Valentine Rd N $229,900 $124 2016-01-22 1997 1,841 Resale 1508 Lochinvar Lane $249,900 $136 2016-05-11 1989 1,841 Resale 10980 Heartwood Hills $259,000 $124 2016-05-13 1989 2,085 Resale 10465 Valentine Rd S $395,000 $132 2016-05-18 1995 2,998 Resale 1610 Baum Rd $195,000 $122 2016-05-25 1995 1,597 Resale 10503 Casanova Drive $300,000 $158 2016-06-24 1997 1,895 Resale 10453 Valentine Rd S $309,000 $133 2016-06-29 2000 2,322 Resale 1622 Shakespeare $367,900 $142 2016-09-16 1995 2,590 Resale 10520 Casanova Drive $335,000 $146 2016-10-07 1994 2,288 Resale 10505 Valentine Rd S $209,000 $87 2016-10-28 1996 2,392 Resale 10533 Valentine Road $240,000 $140 2016-12-29 1993 1,720 Resale 10510 Faye Way $122,500 $41 2016-12-30 2014 3,004 Resale 1513 Lochinvar Ln $78,100 $44 2017-01-18 1996 1,779 Resale 10466 Valentine Road $300,000 $155 2017-03-03 1999 1,930 Resale 10499 Casanova Drive $350,000 $119 2017-04-24 1995 2,932 Resale 10511 Casanova Drive $367,000 $157 2017-06-05 1994 2,340 Resale 10510 Faye Way $400,000 $133 2017-06-26 2017 3,004 New 1513 Lochinvar Ln $261,100 $147 2017-08-11 1996 1,779 Resale 10545 Valentine Rd S $410,000 $123 2017-09-25 2002 3,346 Resale 10478 Valentine Rd S $284,000 $129 2017-10-03 1998 2,200 Resale 1629 Shakespeare $348,000 $145 2018-05-30 2002 2,400 Resale 10600 N Valentine Road $255,000 $157 2018-07-25 1994 1,626 Resale 10577 Valentine Road N $357,000 $143 2018-07-27 2002 2,488 Resale 1602 Shakespeare Drive $305,000 $165 2018-11-19 1998 1,846 Resale 10625 N Valentine Road $345,000 $157 2019-04-17 1997 2,193 Resale 10522 Faye Way $253,700 $60 2019-07-23 1999 4,186 Resale 1501 Lochinvar Lane $340,000 $136 2019-08-26 1992 2,500 Resale 10972 Heartwood Hills Boulevard $428,000 $125 2019-08-28 1994 3,411 Resale 10522 Faye Way $253,620 $61 2019-09-30 1999 4,186 Resale 10532 Casanova Dr $290,000 $163 2020-01-07 2002 1,769 Resale 10465 Valentine Rd S $370,000 $128 2020-06-09 1995 2,901 Resale 1512 Lochinvar Lane $265,000 $152 2020-07-02 1990 1,744 Resale 10517 Valentine Road $350,000 $147 2020-08-19 1991 2,382 Resale 10522 Faye Way $499,000 $119 2020-11-20 1999 4,186 Resale 10466 Valentine Road $355,000 $184 2021-02-11 1999 1,930 Resale 10504 Casanova Drive $416,000 $186 2021-08-20 1993 2,235 Resale 10495 Casanova Drive $484,900 $178 2021-09-03 1996 2,725 Resale 10590 Valentine Rd N $467,500 $229 2021-09-15 1991 2,035 Resale 10457 Valentine Road $525,000 $150 2022-02-11 1996 3,496 Resale 10609 Valentine Rd N $375,000 $143 2022-03-15 1997 2,628 Resale 10636 Valentine Road $510,000 $150 2022-05-27 1990 3,400 Resale 10552 Valentine S Road $413,000 $229 2023-05-30 1993 1,800 Resale 10600 Valentine Rd N $368,000 $226 2023-06-12 1994 1,626 Resale 10601 Valentine Road $465,000 $159 2024-03-18 1991 2,928 Resale 10573 Valentine N Road $506,000 $202 2025-03-14 1997 2,507 Resale 10499 Casanova Drive $540,000 $197 2025-06-18 1995 2,748 Resale 10609 N Valentine Road $499,000 $186 2025-10-24 1997 2,681 Resale 10609 Valentine Rd N $499,000 $189 2025-10-24 1997 2,628 Resale 10571 N Valentine $385,000 $225 2025-10-30 1997 1,710 Resale
Housing Crash or Boom? Here’s What’s Coming in 2025
BIGGEST Housing Market Myth EXPOSED by New Foreclosure Data
There are a lot of people who endorse Joe for the job of selling your home, including Preston Scott (host of Tallahassee's top daily "Audio Magazine," as well as the thousands of happy customers Joe has helped in the past. Listen why!
