Real Estate Conspiracy Pondered By Home Owner

Posted by Joe Manausa on Wednesday, April 14th, 2010 at 11:20am.

Best Theme For Wordpress Gets BetterIs there a real estate industry conspiracy against people selling their house "For Sale By Owner?" Is there a secret network of agent informants who publish a list of homes for sale in Tallahassee that should be avoided at all costs?

This question was posed on a national real estate aggregate site by a frustrated homeowner who wondered why real estate agents were not showing her home. I occasionally prowl these sites to see if there are any interesting real estate topics to write about, and I found the following question posted by a very unhappy homeowner:

Is there a "secret handshake" agreement among realtors that they will not cooperate with FSBO sales even if offered a decent commission? I am getting some traffic in showings but noticeably less than with my previous agent, who did not make much effort to market my property. And my property is listed on the MLS through one of the flat fee broker services so it is in there.

I'm surprised in this market they aren't more self-interested in getting a possible decent commission than in squeezing out the "competition" of a FSBO seller. I've even emailed all the local agents and those who had previously sent me their own marketing materials that the house is listed and we are very interested in working with buyer's agents, big commission etc. Am I paranoid or are they in fact out to get me?

When I read this reader's question, I could immediately see the frustration in her writing. The reason that I chose this question to write about is that it contains three great bullets that really point out the fallacy of "going it alone" in the toughest real estate market that homeowners have faced during my 20 years in the business (and most likely much longer than that).

Do Home Sellers Need A Listing Company?

I believe home sellers need a company to advocate for the value in their home. The experience that this reader shares shows that even an agent "who did not make much effort" to market her property got noticeably more traffic than she is getting without a third party advocate. Perhaps that agent was doing more work behind the scenes than she understood before she tried it on her own.

Is Being In The MLS Enough?

This is very important to note, because being in the MLS guarantees that the property will show up on all the large real estate sites on the internet. We know that 94% of home buyers use the internet during their purchase, so this is important, right?

Obviously, being in the MLS and being on these sites is not enough, there needs to be a strategy on how the property appears on these sites. We take a good bit of time explaining our strategy to home owners on how we use the internet (and the MLS) to get their home sold, because just being on the internet (and the MLS) is not enough in today's very competitive real estate market.

Why Do Some Home Sellers Not "Get It?"

I don't know if anybody else reading her question had the same "Ah Ha" hit them, but she is absolutely backwards in her final question. I find her thinking so broken that I underlined it in the quote so that it wasn't missed by anybody, and I will repeat it here:

I'm surprised in this market they aren't more self-interested in getting a possible decent commission

This question shows she doesn't understand that there are not enough buyers to go around for every seller. Sure, we're going to work hard to sell the homes we were hired to sell. It's not that we are trying to "not sell hers," rather our focus is on selling the ones we were hired to sell. And as far as self-interests go, I can promise you that real estate agent self interest is at an all time high. Motivating the sales force is absolutely critical in this real estate market. But, uh, Ms. Home Seller, don't forget there is an over-abundance of supply, fewer buyers, and the majority of homes on the market are not going to sell!

I am shocked that somebody who needs to sell a home does not understand how important having great help is in this toughest market of our time. Do they really think that real estate agents have a list of "naughty and nice" and only the ones playing by the rules will get sold? Are you crazy?

What this reader needs to know is that there are tons of "decent commissions" to be earned out there. She has more competition than she can handle (obviously) so there does not need to be any conspiracy. Just being in the MLS is not enough (see our report on MLS failure rates).

How To Hire The Best Real Estate Advocate

In my opinion, she has chosen to go it alone and is finding the going very lonely. She should hire an advocate to help her get her home sold (and I even know the best real estate agent in her market!).

If you have a home to sell outside of Tallahassee, we can help you find the best company and the best agent in your real estate market area. We know the questions to ask and we won't get "snowed" by agents who have a great pitch, but no follow-up. We won't charge you anything for this service, just make sure you tell your friends in Tallahassee that we can help them sell their homes!

Joe Manausa, MBA is a 26 year veteran of real estate brokerage in Tallahassee, Florida and has owned and managed his own company since 1992. He is a daily blogger with content that focuses on real estate analytics and providing his clients with a tactical advantage in today's challenging market.

2 Responses to "Real Estate Conspiracy Pondered By Home Owner"

Paul wrote: Ok, so let's ask ourselves why this lady has decided to go FSBO. Lets try exorbitant commissions being the norm. Lets try RE Agents worldwide having a lower standing than politicians for trustworthyness, honesty etc. And yes, not all RE Agents are like that but all are tarred with the same brush. How about RE Agents who would rather make the sale and lose their customer $1000's because the difference in commission for getting an extra (say) $5000 on the sale price is not worth it. Just make the sale and go on to the next one and make the sale quickly again and go on to... well you get the idea. How about pushing Auctions as the best way to sell a house? For the Agent yes, the seller no... after all the seller pays the advertising whether the house sells or not and a commission on top if it does. Do they get the best price? Almost never! Because there are many reasons why people who are interested in a house might not arrive on auction day, traffic delays, family illness or bereavement, prior committments which they cannot break etc. And at the end of the day, IF the house sells, it will be for slightly more than the second highest bidder was willing or able to pay. Yet the buyer who is successful may have been willing to pay 5, 10, 20 thousand more. Of course you'll never know, unless you ask the buyer afterwards.

Personally, I don't blame the lady for wanting to FSBO. Until ethics is the driving force behind the vast majority of RE Agents, then they will continue to be distrusted. Look for more answers at wwwdotjenmandotcomdotau (not associated or affiliated with them in any way, shape or form). New Zealand's Real Estate Laws were overhauled in 2009 because of dishonesty in the profession. Complaints since the new Real Estate Agents Authority have reached about 320 in just the first 5 months of its operations. Previously when complaints were laid, it was to a complaints committee run by the Real Estate Institute of New Zealand. A closed old boys type network. Average complaints? About 10 a year. Maximum penalty a paltry $NZ 500

Is it any wonder why people don't trust real estate agents?

Posted on Tuesday, April 20th, 2010 at 11:46pm.

George Hampton wrote: The arguments that a seller's agent was needed made sense back in 2010. But now in 2015, the market is much, much better. And I have a friend who has been trying to sell a property which is in the best location with features that other condos at the same or even higher price do not have. She gets a ton of spam calls from real estate agents. The few people who have seen the condo said it shows great. But no offers except one real estate agent who actually thought an offer 40% less than comps was OK. The reason: FSBO. Real estate agents are in fact corrupt. One retired agent would not even talk to my friend in a social group after she told him FSBO. Is being a realtor a career or a cult?!?

Posted on Tuesday, November 10th, 2015 at 11:39am.

Leave a Comment