Pending Home Sales Report - Lies, Damned Lies, And Statistics

Posted by Joe Manausa on Friday, November 30th, 2012 at 11:30am.

Numbers can be powerfully persuasive, as we can see from the most recent Pending Home Sales Index from the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR).

This monthly report brings to mind a phrase often attributed to Mark Twain, who said:

There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics.

This month's report from the NAR is very bright and cheery, and it points to an amazing run of year over year gains.

But when we put the NAR numbers to a graph, it is hard to discover the cause for their exuberance.

US Pending Home Sales

If you read the October Pending Home Sales news release, you will find an excited Lawrence Yun reporting that

pending home sales are at the highest level since March 2007 when the index also reached 104.8. On a year-over-year basis, pending home sales have risen for 18 consecutive months.

When I graph the NAR data however, I find a rather underwhelming picture.

US PHSI

The real estate graph above has data going back to April 2010 (when sales were artificially stimulated by the Homebuyer Tax Credit). As you can see, the market has not even returned to the contract level of 2010, and there are reasons beyond buyer consumption to expect our numbers to be much higher.

Short sales have a higher fall-out rate than do traditional "arms length" sales, so it is expected that our contract activity will increase, even if sales stay flat. That's right, much of the rise in the PHSI is purely due to the higher fall-out ratio produced from an increase is distressed properties for sale.

Southern Pending Home Sales

When we isolate the South from the rest of the US, NAR tells us that

Pending home sales in the South rose 5.5 percent to an index of 117.3 in October and are 17.4 percent higher than a year ago.

The graph does show a healthy rise, but like the US figures, we are still below the April 2010 level of activity.

Pending Home Sales Index South

Tallahassee Pending Home Sales

The NAR report does not drill down to the Tallahassee real estate market, but fortunately we track that here :).

And unlike NAR which uses 20% of the  data to produce their estimated reports, our graph uses 100% of the new contract data from the Tallahassee MLS.

Tallahassee's information is consistent with the rest of the South, rising nicely over the past year but still well below where we have been in the past. The real question is how much of this rise is due to short sales and foreclosures that will not close (often times, these properties report multiple buyers, but only one can close).

Pending Home Sales Index Tallahassee

Activity is rising among buyers, and so long as interest rates remain at these crazy low levels, I think we can expect continued improvement in the number of new contracts being written each month. Hopefully, we will see this transfer over to more closed home sales as well.

If you would like to know how the most current trends in pending home sales impact your ability to sell a home, just drop me a note and we can schedule a time to address your unique and specific situation.

Joe Manausa, MBA is a 23+ year veteran of real estate brokerage in the State of Florida and has owned and managed his own company since 1992. He is a daily blogger with content that focuses on real estate analytics and providing his clients with a tactical advantage in today's challenging market.

9 Responses to "Pending Home Sales Report - Lies, Damned Lies, And Statistics"

Eva Armstrong wrote: Joe - if I understand your argument, NAR is using contract data, as opposed to sales data to make their case for the rosy real estate picture?

Why doesn't NAR use sales data?

If sales are used with the Tallahassee data, what do we look like?

Eva

Posted on Friday, November 30th, 2012 at 12:23pm.

Joe Manausa, MBA wrote: Thanks Eva. They do use sales data. But in a separate report.

You can see the corresponding sales data in the recent <a href="http://www.manausa.com/tallahassee-home-sales-rise-market-bottom/" title="Home Sales Tallahassee" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">Tallahassee Home Sales Report</a>.

Posted on Friday, November 30th, 2012 at 12:26pm.

Connor MacIvor wrote: Way to go Joe. I hit you on Google Plus too. I'm always amazed how the numbers can be bent to influence any decision within real estate. They can be jostled to make a buyer want to buy and a seller want to sell. Apparently, even the "leadership" is accustomed to using this tactic to motivate and prod the buyers and sellers of the world.

Posted on Friday, November 30th, 2012 at 12:28pm.

Joe Manausa, MBA wrote: Yeah Connor, I agree that leadership is missing from the "leadship" at NAR.

Posted on Friday, November 30th, 2012 at 12:34pm.

Ken Montville wrote: NAR is always painting a rosy picture of home sales. Even in the depths of the depression, er, I mean recession they were shouting, "Now is the time to buy." It became so ubiquitous that it was like the white noise people use to go to sleep.

NAR, unfortunately, is clueless about a lot of stuff. They're good at collecting money (through dues), investing money (in commercial real estate in Chicago) and lobbying Congress.

My biggest issue with NAR is that they believe that the membership will march lockstep behind whatever banner they raise. It's insane. The numbers juggling is just another example.

Posted on Saturday, December 1st, 2012 at 10:41pm.

Joe Manausa, MBA wrote: Thanks Ken. I wish we could get them to fill a useful capacity. They have data that would really help us project into the future.

Posted on Sunday, December 2nd, 2012 at 9:14am.

Martha Stanton-Smith wrote: I wholeheartedly agree with your assessment of the statistics situation and Ken Montville's comments about the over optimism of NAR. Funny thing, I have never heard a Realtor following a lead for a listing tell the potential client "not a good time to sell". Maybe NAR is just reflecting attitude of its members? Thanks for telling it like it is.

Posted on Sunday, December 2nd, 2012 at 12:25pm.

Joe Manausa, MBA wrote: That's a good point Martha. Maybe the NAR staff thinks the majority of its members wants market disinformation ...

Posted on Sunday, December 2nd, 2012 at 12:47pm.

Greg Williamson wrote: The numbers are a flat out lie. Remortgaging a old loan is NOT a new sale. Beating on elderly people doors to get them to take out home equity loans on a paid off house is NOT a new sale. God only knows what else these scumbag bankers are doing to boost numbers. The banks were involved in the 2008 housing scandal and now they are creating a new one with fictitious sales numbers.

Posted on Friday, July 26th, 2013 at 10:43am.

Leave a Comment